A former business administrator who stole more than $1 million from his Upper St. Clair church and used it for himself was sentenced Tuesday to 30 months in federal prison for tax offenses related to the embezzlement.

U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose imposed that term on David Reiter, 52. She also ordered him to pay more than $1.4 million in restitution to the IRS.

Reiter, former administrator at Westminster Presbyterian Church, and his lawyer, David Chontos, had asked that his sentence be served at the same time as a state court sentence of five to 10 years imposed last year for stealing the money.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Greg Melucci did not object and Judge Ambrose granted the request.

Advertise with us

The earliest release date for Reiter in the state system is April 2023, Mr. Chontos said.

Reiter had pleaded guilty to 16 federal counts in December, including willful failure to pay employment payroll taxes and filing false income tax returns in connection with the money he systematically embezzled over many years.

Addressing the judge by video from the Butler County Prison, Reiter said he was "responsible and accountable" for harming his church by taking its money and the United States by not paying taxes he owed.

"I am deeply and truly sorry for allowing these sins to enter and control me," he told the judge.

He acknowledged that he had harmed thousands of people in the church, as well as his immediate family and his three children, and explained that he had been in the grips of an "evil materialistic stranglehold" during the years of stealing and not paying taxes.

Advertise with us

"I sincerely and deeply apologize to each and every one of them for what I have done," he said.

Reiter said he has since made positive changes "spiritually, emotionally and physically," rededicating himself to his faith, reconnecting to his estranged family and improving his health by losing some 70 pounds since his arrest in 2019.

Reiter was sentenced in state court in January 2020 to 10 to 20 years for the thefts; the term was later reduced to five to 10 years.

Federal authorities indicted him in September on charges of failure to pay taxes related to the stolen money. He admitted that he failed to pay $805,000 in employee payroll taxes from 2016 to 2018 and did not accurately report his personal income.

The stealing came to light in 2018 when the church's board of directors checked an audit and discovered money was missing from the church bank account and its early childhood education programs. The directors also found improper charges had been made on the church credit card.

Advertise with us

Federal agents said Reiter had been stealing since at least 2011 and used the money for personal expenses and trips to Disney World, King's Island and other amusement parks.

In sentencing papers, although not in court, Mr. Chontos lay much of the blame on Reiter's ex-wife, Connie Jo Reiter, whom he said had subjected his client to emotional abuse and pressured him to provide a lifestyle that he could not afford.

She pleaded no contest to conspiracy and receiving stolen property and received three years of probation, with one year on house arrest.