A federal judge was correct to dismiss a racial discrimination suit brought by a woman who said BNY Mellon illegally fired her after she said on Facebook that a motorist should have used a bus to run over people protesting the police shooting of a Black teenager, an appellate court has ruled.

The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday upheld U.S. District Judge Nora Barry Fischer, who last May tossed out a suit by former BNY Mellon analyst Lisa Ellis.

Ms. Ellis, who is white, said in her suit that a Black BNY vice president of human resources, Nicole Manns, orchestrated her firing in the wake of the shooting of Antwon Rose II in June 2018.

Ms. Ellis, of Mt. Lebanon, said she was fired July 3 of that year because of her race.

Advertise with us

The bank said it fired her because she violated its code of conduct and because her performance was not up to par.

After the Antwon Rose shooting, Ms. Ellis went on her Facebook page to comment on a news story about a Bell Acres councilman who drove through a group of protesters on the North Shore. She wrote: “Total BS. Too bad he didnt [sic] have a bus to plow thru.”

To bring a race discrimination suit, the 3rd Circuit said, Ms. Ellis had to show that her firing was because of her race.

Judge Fischer said she presented no evidence that it was.

In challenging that decision, Ms. Ellis and her lawyer relied on comparisons to other employees at the bank.

Advertise with us

She said two BNY employees, both Black, also shared controversial social media posts but were not fired.

But the 3rd Circuit said those situations were different.

“What matters most is that Ellis’s social media post was far more egregious — and far more likely to harm BNY Mellon’s reputation,” wrote Judge Cheryl Ann Krause. “Neither supposedly-similar employee said anything as extreme.”

One expressed frustration with a white co-worker but didn’t threaten anyone. The other said men who hurt women should kill themselves.

“Though inappropriate and ill-advised, neither post encouraged mass violence against protesters, as Ellis’s did. Thus, no reasonable jury could find Ellis’s conduct comparable to that of her former colleagues.”