A Brentwood restaurant known to shun COVID-19 mitigation measures lost its legal fight against the Allegheny County Health Department and must comply with the agency or face closure, a judge ruled Wednesday.

The opinion from Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge John T. McVay Jr. said the Crack’d Egg restaurant failed to prove that the COVID-19 rules were unconstitutional or that enforcement of the regulations would be more harmful than the financial woes incurred by restrictions.

The restaurant argued in a three-day virtual hearing that the county Health Department and the state lacked the authority to enforce mitigation orders.

But Judge McVay, relying on a 2020 Pennsylvania Supreme Court case upholding Gov. Tom Wolf’s closure of “non-life sustaining” businesses, said the case law affirmed the governor’s broad emergency powers amid a pandemic.

Advertise with us

Likewise, he said, the county Health Department is authorized to oversee health laws, rules and regulations by enforcing Mr. Wolf’s and the state Department of Health’s orders, which included requiring people to wear face coverings and restricting restaurants’ indoor capacity.

“Once the ACHD discovers a nuisance detrimental to the health and well-being of the public, the health director is authorized to take action to abate the nuisance,” Judge McVay wrote.

The department was “not only authorized but mandated” to enforce the governor’s orders, he wrote.

In testimony, Crack’d Egg owner Kimberly Waigand said she would never comply with the Health Department’s mask rules. “I ask her to reconsider and work with the health department to come up with a COVID-19 mitigation plan,” the judge wrote.

Attorneys for the restaurant said they planned to appeal the decision.

Advertise with us

“While we have great respect for Judge McVay both as a person and jurist, we obviously disagree with his ruling and are disappointed to the outcome,” defense attorney Sy Lampl said.

Although the county ordered the restaurant to close due to noncompliance, in this case it was not seeking the eatery’s closure but was asking the Crack’d Egg to agree to follow the rules.

The judge ordered the location to submit a compliance plan to the county Health Department and to cease operating in violation of the agency’s closure order.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli.