The Allegheny County District Attorney’s office has refiled charges against 24 people for failure to disperse during May 30 and June 1 protests after initially deciding not to prosecute based on a lack of evidence.

Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said Mayor Bill Peduto directed police to submit more evidence, which the DA’s office then used to refile the charges. That statement, however, prompted the mayor to accuse the top prosecutor of “spreading disinformation.”

Most participants in the protests, which sprung up in the aftermath of the killing of George Floyd, were peaceful. But several people were charged with crimes related to vandalism and throwing projectiles at police.

A curfew was set, leading to the arrests of 61 people for failure to disperse after they refused to leave when police declared the demonstration to be unlawful. Mr. Zappala dropped all of those charges after he determined they “were badly lacking in evidentiary sufficiency,” he wrote in a statement Friday.

Advertise with us

But more evidence gathered by Pittsburgh police, including body camera and surveillance video, shows people refusing to leave after they were repeatedly directed to disperse, Mr. Zappala said in the statement.

“Recently, at the direction of Mayor Peduto, the Pittsburgh Police presented to my office tangible evidence for the refiling of these Failure to Disperse charges in the form of body camera footage, as well as surveillance video and more comprehensive investigations,” Mr. Zappala said in the statement.

The charges are summonses — equivalent to a traffic ticket — and most of the people charged will be offered community service. Their names have not yet been released because some have not yet received a summons, Mr. Zappala said.

Mr. Peduto’s office took exception to Mr. Zappala’s statement that the mayor was involved.

“The Mayor has no role in the investigation of criminal activity, the presentation of evidence to the DA or the filing of charges in this case or any other case ever,” a spokesman wrote in an email.

Advertise with us

Asked directly whether the mayor told police to pursue the charges or to present them to the DA, the spokesman said no. But the DA’s office said its statement was accurate.

Pittsburgh police directed questions to the mayor’s office.

Mr. Peduto has been a frequent target of activists’ ire. Over the summer, racial justice protesters held demonstrations outside his home in Point Breeze.

Protesters criticized the mayor for being too lax on police reform and pressured him to take broader steps to defund the police and criticize law enforcement’s response to the summer demonstrations, some of which ended with police using tear gas, less-lethal munitions and pepper spray on protesters.

That the mayor would ask police to refile the charges is “insane but totally on brand with how Mayor Peduto has treated Black people and allies rightfully calling for justice in this moment,” activist Jasiri X, the founder of 1Hood Media, wrote on Twitter.

Advertise with us

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli

Correction, posted Jan. 8, 2021: An earlier version of this story misstated who filed charges in the case. The district attorney’s office filed them.