The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled that a receptionist seriously injured in the 2012 Western Psych shooting cannot sue the doctors who decided against involuntarily committing the shooter.

In a 6-1 opinion filed Tuesday, the justices said the state’s Mental Health Procedure Act does not hold physicians liable for discussing, yet failing, to place the shooter in psychiatric care.

The law’s “exclusive, clear and unequivocal” language requires doctors to become formally involved in the decision-making process before they can be held liable, the court decided.

“It is only when a physician files the required documentation for involuntary emergency examination that he becomes a participant in the decision-making process under the Act,” Justice Debra Todd wrote in the 27-page opinion.

Advertise with us

“Moreover, Appellants’ interpretation of the MHPA would, if taken to its logical conclusion, render health care workers potentially liable for any thought or act, no matter how inconsequential, tangentially related to the consideration of an involuntary examination of a patient.”

One person was killed in the March 8, 2012 shooting and several others were injured, including receptionist Kathryn Leight, who was shot in the abdomen and filed the lawsuit. The shooter, John Shick, was killed by a responding University of Pittsburgh police officer.

After a series of voluntary evaluations, which sometimes led to outbursts from Shick, doctors at UPMC Shadyside Family Health Center in February 2012 discussed the possibility of involuntary mental health evaluation, treatment, and commitment, but decided against it, court documents read.

When Shick reappeared at the hospital on Feb. 10, 2012, to have blood drawn, he brandished a baseball bat “in a threatening manner.” Doctors sent a team to his home to assess him for possible commitment to Western Psych, but Shick refused to let them inside.

Doctors at the hospital continued to discuss involuntary commitment for Shick throughout February and eventually notified him that they would no longer be providing medical care to him after conducting a variety of physical tests.

Advertise with us

Although they discussed it, “the physicians did not take part in a decision that Shick be examined or treated under Section 114 [of the MHPA], and, therefore, they were not engaged in an involuntary commitment decision,” Justice Todd wrote.

The justices found that “mere thoughts, considerations or steps” short of the prerequisites that make up an involuntary emergency examination are outside the cause of action described in the MHPA.

Justice Sallie Updyke Mundy wrote the lone dissenting opinion, arguing the discussion among the University of Pittsburgh physicians fell within the scope of the MHPA.

The law’s “language is broad and does not contain any requirement that the physician has to file the required documentation to be considered a participant in the decision-making process,” she wrote in a seven-page dissent.

In the majority’s conclusion, Justice Todd wrote: “Finally, we recognize that Shick’s actions were horrendous, and that the injuring of Kathryn Leight, among others, and the killing of another person was a profound tragedy. However, the issue before our Court is one of statutory liability under the MHPA, and, as explained above, we find its provisions simply do not allow Appellants to pursue a cause of action under the Act in these circumstances.”

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli