Allegheny County has picked an unusual spot to start the process of resuming jury trials: the David L. Lawrence Convention Center.

Jury selection will begin Wednesday in two large convention center halls, each housing a maximum of 80 potential jurors. Chairs will be spread out several feet apart so people can distance themselves from one another. Traffic court already is using the building, and other areas will be used for civil cases.

Jury trials were put on hold in March, when the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ordered all state courts to close during the earliest weeks of the COVID-19 outbreak. Other counties in the region have already resumed jury trials.

“The right to a trial by jury is one of the fundamental rights of U.S. citizenship, but due to the pandemic, there has not been a jury trial held in Allegheny County for the last six months,” Allegheny County Common Pleas President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark wrote in a recent statement.

Advertise with us

“During this time, defendants who are being held in jail, as well as victims and their families, have been waiting for a just resolution of their cases. We must begin to bring resolution and closure to these cases in the safest manner possible.”

The decision to move forward with trials is a difficult balancing act of protecting civil rights and adhering to the advice of public health experts, defense attorney Dave Shrager said, adding, “We can’t suspend people’s constitutional rights, and we can’t put people in harm’s way.”

Mr. Shrager said he believes the county is doing its best to make the process as safe as possible.

It has instituted measures that include spreading jurors out instead of having them sit shoulder to shoulder in the jury box; erecting Plexiglas barriers to protect the judge, witnesses and other court employees; and requiring everyone to wear face coverings inside the convention center. The same rules apply for other proceedings continuing at the Allegheny County Courthouse on Grant Street.

Defense attorney Phil DiLucente said some of his colleagues have expressed concern about returning to the courthouse.

Advertise with us

Russ Broman, a longtime assistant district attorney, died in August after contracting COVID-19. His colleague, Ted Dutkowski, also contracted the virus and was hospitalized as infections spread across the court system in June and July.

But Mr. DiLucente said he had confidence that the court will do what it can to prevent an outbreak.

“The general consensus is that they’re going to follow the [Centers for Disease Control and Prevention] guidelines and avoid spread,” he said.

Measures such as temperature checks at entrances, requiring the public to view proceedings over video feed in a separate room, installing hand-sanitizing stations and screening for symptoms will help keep people safe, said District Court Administrator Chris Connors.

“While no one can guarantee, in any setting, that someone will not get COVID, we have taken precautions to minimize the risk of transmitting the virus during both jury selection and the trial,” Mr. Connors wrote in an email.

Advertise with us

If someone has a temperature of 100.4 degrees or higher, that person will be asked to leave the convention center via a back exit, a measure to protect others in line at the entrance. Jurors can also opt out of duty if they have a health concern.

Mike Feeney, a civil litigator, was one of six members of the Allegheny County Bar Association who gave input to the county on restarting civil trials, which will be held on the third floor of the convention center. Those trials can’t proceed unless all parties agree to move forward, and most people are willing to wait at least a little while longer, Mr. Feeney said.

“The majority view is, there’s no harm in waiting,” Mr. Feeney said of the his colleagues. “Why risk lives to try a case we could try six months from now?”

He sees the current arrangement as a “great compromise” by the court: No one is forced into an unsafe position, but trials are able to move forward if everyone involved agrees to proceed.

The financial effects of the pandemic have some people eager to move forward in civil cases and get a settlement, said Lori Azzara, a construction litigator at the Downtown law firm Cohen Seglias.

Advertise with us

“Even more so now, I think it’s important to be sensitive to how long they’ve been without money,” Ms. Azzara said. She pointed to the ongoing uncertainty of whether courts will stay open if there is a resurgence of infections in the colder months.

Especially in criminal cases, where people may be jailed for months as they await trials, people are anxious to get cases in motion, Mr. DiLucente said. “[Clients are] like, ‘Phil, when’s this gonna end? I want my day in court — I didn’t do anything.’”

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.