Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge John Zottola, who served on the bench for 27 years and founded Western Pennsylvania’s first Veterans Court, died Monday.
Judge Zottola, of Fox Chapel, graduated from Central Catholic High School and the University of Pittsburgh, where he received his law degree in 1982. He worked in Mental Health Court for several years before supervising the Veterans Court in 2009.
His death was due to complications from an infection, according to his office. He was 63.
The judge was inspired to bring the Veterans Court to Allegheny County after learning of a similar court in Buffalo, N.Y. It was created to address the special circumstances that lead veterans to enter the criminal justice system, such as mental illness, the societal pressures of re-entering civilian life, homelessness and substance use.
In 2018, he described the Veterans Court to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette as “a problem-solving court, with positive rewards and regular sanctions.”
District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., a high school friend of Judge Zottola’s, offered his sympathies to the judge’s family.
Read More
“John’s death leaves a tremendous void not only on the bench, but also in our community,” Mr. Zappala said in a statement. “There is no doubt that his work leading Veteran’s Court has saved a large number of lives and assisted in putting veterans, who have given so much to this country, on the path to recovery.
“John took the time to know everyone who appeared before him and when he addressed defendants, he always sought to encourage them to make a positive change not only for themselves, but for their family and friends. John was first and foremost a loving husband and father, as well as a dedicated and passionate jurist. I, along with the rest of this courthouse, will miss him deeply.”
In a statement, Allegheny County President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark said Judge Zottola “was a dedicated public servant who served the court and the citizens of Allegheny County with honor and integrity for more than twenty-six years. He will be remembered for his intelligence, fairness, and even temperament.”
The judge was known for his compassion and as a champion for those who struggled with mental illness. When he received recognition, he was known to divert praise to the people around him.
When he spoke at a 2010 U.S Senate hearing on the need for federal resources to establish more Veterans Courts, he described the program as a “team” approach “where the judge is, if necessary, a speed bump in the decision-making process.”
“Mental Health Court, as well as Veterans Court ... is going to be the right thing to do because the catch-and-release system — where they keep catching individuals that find themselves in the criminal justice system, release them, only to be re-arrested and re-incarcerated — isn't working,” he told the judiciary committee.
Since its inception, there have been as many as 500 veterans involved in the program, according to the district attorney’s office. There were several graduates of the Veterans Court program who, upon finishing the program, told him that he changed their lives, Duquesne University professor Dan Kunz said.
Mr. Kunz, who worked with the judge for 10 years as a supervisor in the Duquesne School of Law Veterans Clinic, said Judge Zottola was thoughtful, intelligent and kind in both his professional and personal life.
The judge took the time to understand and know the participants in the program. “He believed that the individuals that we were seeing in the Veterans Court program weren’t bad people,” Mr. Kunz said. “They had a problem.”
Phil Nassar, the judge’s tipstaff who worked with him for several years, said the judge’s office was numb and in shock from his passing. Judge Zottola was “probably the most wonderful, compassionate man you’ll ever meet,” he said.
“He was the best,” Mr. Nassar said. “This courthouse is full of tears today, for him.”
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli
Correction, made Oct. 13: A previous version of this story misstated the date of Judge Zottola’s death.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.