The Superior Court of Pennsylvania on Tuesday denied an East Hills woman’s appeal after she was convicted last year of manslaughter for killing her daughter by putting fentanyl in the girl’s sippy cup.

Jhenea Pratt, 25, argued that the trial court, when imposing her 5- to 10-year sentence, only considered the nature of her crime, and not her lack of criminal history, her character or rehabilitative needs.

She said the sentence was excessive and unreasonable and asked the Superior Court to vacate the sentencing and to send the case back to the lower court.

The appellate court said the sentencing was not unreasonable.

Advertise with us

The lower court “took into account defense counsel’s argument at sentencing,” in which the counsel “beseeched” the court to acknowledge Pratt’s “age, employment, education, rehabilitative needs, support system and abusive relationship,” Judge Megan McCarthy King wrote in the opinion.

“So, we can presume the court considered and weighed the relevant information and mitigating factors,” the opinion reads.

Prosecutors in the case told jurors that Pratt put fentanyl in her 17-month-old daughter Charlette’s sippy cup so the woman could "sit back, relax and smoke marijuana.”

About an hour later, she checked on the girl, realized she was not breathing and called 911.

According to court records, when first responders arrived, Pratt told them “I can’t get in trouble for this. This cannot be my fault. I am not going to get in trouble for this.”

Advertise with us

The amount of fentanyl found in the child’s body —1,100 nanograms, according to the medical examiner’s office — was enough to kill two horses, prosecutors said. The office listed Charlette’s death as a homicide due to fentanyl poisoning.

“Your primary concern was for yourself,” Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Mark V. Tranquilli said at the hearing. “Your primary concern continues to be for yourself with very little or no thought for your child.

“I find it especially disturbing that you found smoking marijuana to be more important than looking after the only child that it’s likely you’re ever going to have. So, for all of those reasons ...  I am compelled to deviate upward from the [sentencing] guidelines.”

Before her trial, Pratt was found to have made several inconsistent statements about Charlette’s death to her fellow inmates, court records state.

She told an inmate she did not kill Charlette, and then said she did not mean to the kill her. She noted that no one else could have killed her. Pratt also stated that she “didn’t want a damn girl anyway,” court documents said.

Advertise with us

In sentencing Pratt, the court “recited a detailed and thorough explanation of the facts and reasons underlying its sentencing decision,” the Superior Court found. “Therefore, the court did not impose an unreasonable sentence and we see no reason to disrupt the court’s broad sentencing discretion.”

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli