A state appellate court has ruled that a pathologist can testify in the prosecution of a Johnstown man accused of assault after the death of an Indiana University of Pennsylvania student in 2017.

The Superior Court's ruling means that the Indiana County District Attorney's Office can proceed with the trial against Brady DiStefano, 23, in November in the death of Caleb Zweig of Rockville, Md.

The two were IUP fraternity brothers and got into a fight on Feb. 3, 2017. Mr. Zweig died after the altercation.

A three-judge Superior Court panel last Wednesday reversed Indiana County Judge William Martin's ruling that the DA can't use the testimony of the pathologist, Dr. Ashley Zezulak, as to cause of death.

Advertise with us

Last year the judge had said any testimony referencing Mr. Zweig's death was not admissible.

Mr. DiStefano is charged with aggravated assault, but not homicide.

The judge said previously that the prosecution could offer evidence of Mr. Zweig's death as well as a finding by Dr. Zezulak that Mr. Zweig had suffered a scalp wound, but said prosecutors could not present evidence to prove that Mr. DiStefano caused the death.

The DA's office appealed because it wanted to use Dr. Zezulak's opinion that Mr. Zweig's death was caused by asphyxiation "secondary to presumed chokehold and chest compression."

The Superior Court sided with the DA.

Advertise with us

"The weight and persuasiveness of Dr. Zezulak’s testimony will be for the jury to decide," the judges said. "It is well-established that 'jurors, as factfinders, are entrusted with the responsibility of evaluating the evidence and rendering a decision based on the evidence presented and the inferences deduced therefrom.'”

The judges also said there is testimony from a witness, Trevor King, who said he heard the fight and saw Mr. Zweig lying on his back with Mr. DiStefano kneeling over him and his hands on his chest.

Mr. DiStefano and Mr. Zweig got into a scuffle after both had attended a party. Mr. King said he pulled Mr. DiStefano off of Mr. Zweig, who was unresponsive. He was taken to a local hospital where he died.

The DA originally charged Mr. DiStefano with homicide and aggravated assault. Judge Martin threw out the case because he said prosecutors did not present enough evidence that Mr. DiStefano caused Mr. Zweig's death.

The prosecution appealed. The Superior Court upheld the dismissal of the homicide count but reinstated the assault charge.

Advertise with us

The case will now proceed on that count.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.