A serial swindler from Florida who has been in trouble with the law her entire life should get home confinement for a counterfeit check scheme instead of federal prison because of a lifetime of struggles with gender identification issues and because of the coronavirus, her lawyer says.

But U.S. prosecutors want prison, saying she's a career criminal who in more than 24 previous sentencing hearings asked for similar leniency, got it and then went right back to her frauds and schemes.

Calar Braxton, 45, of Orlando, Fla., is set to be sentenced Thursday by video in U.S. District Court for stealing people's mail in Coraopolis and Imperial and using it to make bogus bank checks.

Prosecutors say she and her husband, Brian Campbell, have done the same thing across the U.S. and that Braxton owes nearly $1 million to various victims.

Advertise with us

Assistant U.S. Attorney Mike Ivory said Braxton has "simply not learned that crime does not pay" and asked U.S. District Judge Marilyn Horan for prison because she's had plenty of chances to stop being a criminal.

"Counsel is confident that at over the two-dozen-plus previous sentencing hearings Braxton pleaded with the court for leniency, solemnly promising that she would never engage in additional criminal conduct," he said in a sentencing memo. "Her record belies this supposed earnestness."

Mr. Ivory said Braxton is a "consummate fraudster and recidivist."

But her lawyer, Michael DeRiso, said Braxton has already been in jail for more than 15 months and should get home confinement and probation instead of the guideline sentencing range of 41 to 51 months behind bars.

He said most of her troubles in life have been caused by "extremely bad choices and a desire to find acceptance in a society that judges her unfairly." Born male, Braxton identifies as female and completed her transformation in 2012.

Advertise with us

"Her gender transformation has caused countless problems for her and she struggles to find her way in the world," Mr. DeRiso wrote.

He also cited the virus in asking that Braxton be spared prison, invoking a directive by Attorney General William Barr authorizing the U.S. Bureau of Prisons to increase its use of home confinement instead of incarceration during the pandemic.

Braxton and Campbell, 30, both pleaded guilty last year to conspiracy to pass fake checks in Robinson as part of an interstate fraud scheme centered mostly in the southern U.S.

They flew to Pittsburgh from Florida in 2017 and set up shop in a North Fayette hotel, then drove around stealing outgoing mail from mailboxes in search of checks. When they found one, they used the account information and routing number to make fake checks using a laptop computer and a laser printer.

With the fake checks, they went on shopping sprees at the Mall at Robinson and other retail outlets in that area, including Macy's and Victoria's Secret.

Advertise with us

But the pair had some sloppy habits.

For one thing, they were smoking in a non-smoking room at the hotel, so employees went into the room to look for evidence of smoking and found the laser printer, laptop and a box of blank checks. An employee also found a bag of checks in the hallway.

North Fayette police raided the room and found the printer with blank check stock and 20 checks drawn on SunTrust accounts issued to Taylor Crimson, which is one of Braxton's aliases. They also found a North Carolina driver's license in the Crimson name as well as unopened mail from residents of Coraopolis and Imperial and 54 other pieces of mail from Orlando residents.

A search of Braxton's purse turned up fake driver's licenses from Tennessee and Georgia.

Braxton and Campbell admitted as part of their pleas that they had traveled throughout the South, passing bogus checks in Alabama, Florida, Georgia, North and South Carolina and Texas.