This is a running list of witnesses called each day during the trial of Cheron Shelton, 33, of Lincoln-Lemington, who is accused of killing five people and an unborn child on March 9, 2016, at a backyard barbecue on Franklin Avenue in Wilkinsburg.

The victims: Siblings Jerry Michael Shelton, 35, Brittany Powell, 27, and Chanetta Powell, 25, who was eight months pregnant; and their cousins Tina Shelton, 37, and Shada Mahone, 26.

Day 3, Feb. 5, 2020

1. Allegheny County police Detective Kevin McCue, on the stand for 6 minutes.

Advertise with us

Detective McCue, who had been on the stand at the end of Day 2, was cross-examined about video showing activity around 1214 Nolan Court, the home of Shelton’s mother, on the night of the shooting.

He said he believed that the person seen entering the townhouse was Cheron Shelton.

The detective testified that he did not know that the next-door neighbor was the sister of Lamont Powell, the suspected target of the shooting, who was wounded. He also acknowledged that he did not investigate who Shelton might have been talking to that night or determine who lived next to Shelton’s mother.

2. Allegheny County police Detective James Holman, on the stand for 16 minutes.

Detective Holman, who works in the video forensic unit, extracted the sound of the gunfire from the shooting incident that was recorded by a home audio system in the neighborhood.

Advertise with us

Audio of the shots was played for the jury, and then Detective Holman explained how to read two different charts, one green and the other shaded from yellow to red, depicting a graphical representation of the sounds of the shots — 18 from a .40-caliber handgun and 30 from a gun firing larger 7.62-caliber bullets.

“It’s kind of like a fingerprint for that particular sound,” the detective said.

3. William Best, who works in the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s forensic laboratory division, on the stand for 34 minutes.

Mr. Best participated in collecting and photographing evidence recovered by police from 1214 Nolan Court in Homewood, the home of Shelton’s mother,on March 12, 2016, three days after the shooting.

He walked the jury through pictures of a .22-caliber rifle, several magazines containing 7.62-caliber ammunition, a black bag with a gun scope and other firearm parts, and a white bulletproof vest. The materials were found in the basement, some inside a red suitcase.

Advertise with us

There was also a piece of mail address to Shelton.

Mr. Best removed some of the materials from evidence bags and displayed them for the jury.

He also testified that a floor mat and part of the floorboard on the front passenger side of a white Lincoln Continental registered to Shelton’s sister, Brittany Shelton, were stained and tested positive for the “presumptive presence for blood.” He said he also processed a gold Buick LaCrosse registered to Shelton’s girlfriend, Channel Falls.

Cross-examination of Mr. Best did not occur for unknown reasons.

4. Leroy Hicks, who lived near the shooting scene, on the stand for 1 minute.

Advertise with us

Mr. Hicks said that at the time of the shooting he lived across the street and three to four houses away from 1304 Franklin Ave.

He said he had a surveillance system that he gave to Wilkinsburg police.

5. Allegheny County police Detective Mike Feeney, on the stand for 30 minutes.

Detective Feeney discussed the video taken from Mr.Hicks’ two exterior cameras, which captured a white sedan driving up Franklin Avenue at 10:41 p.m. on the night of the shooting, which happened around 12 minutes later.

Some of the video captured first responders coming into view on the video, and Detective Feeney said, “It’s not clear enough to tell who it might be, but you can see the movements of people.”

Advertise with us

6. Penn Hills police Officer David Pine, on the stand for 21 minutes.

Officer Pine was working the graveyard shift on March 9-10, 2016 when he responded to a call around 2:18 a.m.for a prowler in the 3000 block of Hebron Drive.

He said he and two other officers arrived at the same time to find a man in the street on the phone.

The man, who had no identification, told Officer Pine that he had lost his phone in the grass earlier and found it just before police arrived.

Officer Pine said the man gave his name as Cheron Shelton and provided his birthdate, and police were able to verify his identity with a picture they obtained.

Advertise with us

Shelton was described as being polite and cooperative — and sober with no signs of being intoxicated. Police let Shelton go after no more than eight minutes of interaction with him, and he walked away.

Officer Pine said on cross-examination that Shelton told him he had been drinking with a friend earlier. Shelton had no weapons and gave no reason for anyone to believe he had been involved in a crime, the officer said.

7. Penn Hills police Officer David Klobucher, on the stand for 11 minutes.

Officer Klobucher echoed Officer Pine’s testimony about the encounter with Shelton in Penn Hills several hours after the shooting.

He also said Shelton did not appear to be intoxicated.

Advertise with us

Officer Klobucher said he patted down Shelton, but only the pockets of his outer garments.

Asked by defense attorney Randall McKinney whether he noticed any blood on his hands after the pat down and going into Shelton’s pockets, the officer said no.

8. Penn Hills police Officer Dennis Robl, on the stand for 3 minutes.

Officer Robl’s testimony largely mirrored that of his colleagues who interacted with Shelton early March 10, 2016.

Asked on cross-examination if he had seen Shelton around a white Lincoln Continental, he said no.

Advertise with us

9. Jason Clark, scientist with the medical examiner’s office, on the stand for 25 minutes.

Mr. Clark talked about fingerprints and explained to the jury via a slide presentation how he analyzes prints from unknown subjects and matches them to known subjects.

In a dramatic moment, Assistant District Attorney Lisa Pellegrini held up the .22-caliber rifle recovered from the home of Shelton’s mother and asked if prints were recovered. Mr. Clark testified that a print from Shelton was found.

But immediately on cross-examination, Mr. Clark acknowledged that the rifle was not alleged to have been used in the shooting.

10. Robert McNeal, a jitney driver, on the stand for 7 minutes.

Advertise with us

Mr. McNeal said he knew Shelton and his former co-defendant, Robert Thomas, and used to give them rides in his capacity as a jitney. He said homicide detectives interviewed him four times and showed him phone records.

“They said they had my number in Rob’s phone, and I called him the night of and the day of the shooting,” Mr. McNeal said. “I didn’t talk to him because I had a bad signal.”

He said the police told him the two were suspects in the homicides.

“He was a good guy. He was my friend,” Mr. McNeal said of Thomas. “They asked me if I thought they did it. I said, “I don’t think so.’ “

Mr. McNeal said he used to live in Homewood’s Hilltop section, where Shelton and Thomas are from.

Advertise with us

11. Robert Barko, Allegheny County Emergency Services Department’s 911 records custodian, on the stand for 4 minutes.

Mr. Barko reviewed the 911 call from Penn Hills, which was played for the jury.

The male caller told 911 that he saw two men in hooded sweatshirts who he didn’t recognize “creeping around”on Hebron Drive at 2:18 a.m.

12. Allegheny County police Lt. Venerando Costa, on the stand for 1 hour and 32 minutes.

Lt. Costa read for the jury two letters written by Cheron Shelton from the Allegheny County Jail that police intercepted. One was to his girlfriend, Channel Falls; the other was to Ms. Falls’ father, Adrien Falls.

Advertise with us

The lieutenant said that investigators intercepted the mail after listening to a recorded jail phone call — played in court -—between Shelton and one of his sisters, Brittany Shelton, in which the defendant seemed to speak in code and indicated that he would be sending a letter.

Lt. Costa confirmed that police executed numerous search warrants after reading Shelton’s letters in an effort to find any evidence tying him to the Wilkinsburg shootings. He admitted that the warrants did not yield such evidence.

He also testified bout executing a search warrant on a gold Chevrolet Impala registered to Shelton’s sister, Ashley Smith, that contained two cell phones. In the trunk was a blue pillowcase with what appeared to be blood, and inside the pillowcase was a multicolored towel with red and blue stains. Police said in the criminal complaint against Shelton that Shelton and Thomas were seen on video at 12:23 a.m. on March 10, 2016 leaving 1214 Nolan Court and putting a black bag inside a gold Impala’s trunk.

13. Samuel Pastor, Allegheny County Jail internal affairs investigator, on the stand for 13 minutes.

Mr. Pastor explained how the phone system works between inmates and visitors.

He also described how Shelton was held in restricted housing, locked down for 23 hours a day.