An Allegheny County judge Monday sentenced a Stowe man to life in prison without parole for fatally beating a 73-year-old man in 2016.
Police said that Branden A. Frazier, 28, killed Benito Nicoletti in the victim’s McKees Rocks home and then stole his rented Chrysler 300 sedan. Mr. Nicoletti’s body was found on June 1, 2016, and Frazier was arrested two days later.
On Oct. 7, a jury found Frazier guilty of first-degree murder as well as burglary, receiving stolen property and theft.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Kevin G. Sasinoski tacked on an extra 10 to 21 years in prison to Frazier’s life sentence in connection with the other charges.
Although the district attorney’s office had initially planned to seek the death penalty, the prosecution later withdrew its intention.
Marvin Leibowitz, Frazier’s lawyer, said he plans to appeal the verdict but declined to elaborate on his strategy.
Read More
“I am a great believer in the jury system, but I just believe that the jury got it wrong in convicting him of first-degree murder,” Mr. Leibowitz said.
On the evening of June 1, 2016, the victim’s daughter and her fiance found Mr. Nicoletti dead and lying face up on a sofa in his living room on Vine Street, according to a criminal complaint.
Investigators found blood splattered on the walls, ceiling and objects surrounding Mr. Nicoletti. An autopsy showed that he died from head injuries after being struck multiple times by a blunt, heavy object, the complaint said.
The day after the slaying, a man who recognized the Chrysler from the news called 911 because he had spotted the car in the 600 block of Woodward Avenue in Stowe, near Mancini’s Bakery — and across the street from Frazier’s home.
Kelsey Frazier, Mr. Frazier’s sister, told police that she remembered seeing her brother get out of a parked car across the street from her residence, and that the car was not his. She wrote the number on the registration plate down on an envelope.
When Frazier saw the envelope, he became angry, grabbed the paper from her and threatened to kill his sister and their great-aunt, Vicki Myers, the complaint said.
Detectives executed a search warrant on Frazier’s home and found a blood-stained pair of blue jeans inside a back pack, the complaint said.
According to police, around 10 p.m. on the night Mr. Nicoletti’s body was found, one of the victim’s neighbors said he had heard someone running up and down the stairs leading to the vacant apartment above his.
When Qyidaar Knox opened the door to investigate, the man asked where he could buy a gun and also said that he had just been released from prison and was looking for a place to live, according to the complaint.
Abigail Mihaly: amihaly@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.