In the last 29 years, John Dickinson has spent just 21 months — in spurts — as a free man.
During much of his time incarcerated, he has been held in solitary confinement.
And now, it is likely he faces a similar punishment for the rest of his life.
Dickinson, 43, pleaded guilty but mentally ill on Monday to first-degree murder for the death and dismemberment of a man he once dated.
Kevin Thompson, 46, was reported missing on May 31, 2018, and his body was found the next day in pieces inside garbage bags in the shed and basement of his home on Parkfield Street in Carrick.
Dickinson, who had been out of prison less than three months and moved in with Mr. Thompson, was charged in his death a day later.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Anthony M. Mariani ordered Dickinson to spend the rest of his life in prison with no chance for parole.
It was a sentence Dickinson welcomed.
"I'm ready, let's go," he told the judge "I know that I'm guilty of murder in the first degree, and I know that I'm mentally ill."
Forensic psychologist Alice Applegate testified that Dickinson is "a traumatized schizoaffective psychopath."
Reading from a statement he had folded in the pocket of his restricted-housing unit uniform from the jail, Dickinson apologized to Mr. Thompson's mother, as well as to the couple who took him in when he was only 2..
"I brought nothing but pain and embarrassment to my parents, and they've done nothing but love me," he said. "I'm unlovable.
"Some people do not belong in the free world."
Dickinson, who has previous convictions for aggravated assault, robbery and other counts, told Judge Mariani that out of all of his incarceration, 11 years of it has been spent alone in solitary confinement.
"I really believe it has damaged my brain," he told the judge.
But Ms. Applegate testified that Dickinson has a history of early childhood abuse and neglect, and several close family members who have been diagnosed with schizophrenia, including his mother, who was just 14 when she had him, as well as his brother and grandmother.
He had an IQ of 132 when he was 5 years old, but at age 43, Ms. Applegate wrote, it was at 95.
"The decline in John’s intellectual levels may be related to the fade-out effect in childhood/adolescence, to schizophrenic cognitive decline in adulthood, and to possible brain damage from historical huffing," Ms. Applegate wrote.
Dickinson began cutting himself at age 12 to release frustration, she wrote, and began setting fires in his early teens. One family member reported to Ms. Applegate that Dickinson was raped while he was held at Shuman Juvenile Detention Center, and that he was homeless, addicted to drugs and worked as a prostitute in young adulthood.
“John exhibits many bizarre behaviors — including nightmares and very violent images, and he’s not in control with these things," Ms. Applegate told Judge Mariani.
In the past, she said, he has been diagnosed with schizoaffective disorder, bipolar disorder, borderline personality disorder and antisocial personality disorder.
“He says, ‘I’m a wolf. I’m a homicidal psychopath,’” Ms. Applegate testified. He told her that “he went into the juvenile system as a sheep, came out a wolf and will never be a sheep again.”
Patrick Nightingale, Dickinson’s attorney, said that his client’s history dictates that he likely will spend the rest of his life segregated from general population in state prison.
He has repeatedly been charged with assault in prison — of other inmates and correctional officers. He has been found with homemade weapons and has attempted to set his cell on fire. Once he burned his arm and then smeared it with feces, Ms. Applegate wrote in her report. He has also swallowed "a handful of straightened staples," as well as part of a razor blade and toothbrush. He has thrown urine on correctional officers.
Dickinson has accrued more than 100 misconducts during his incarceration.
One test administered by Ms. Applegate showed that Dickinson is "highly predisposed to violence.”
Later, in her report she wrote that Dickinson told her, "If I didn’t take Prozac, I’d be a homicidal maniac. I want to kill someone — everybody. I became homicidal 10 to 15 years ago.
"One day, I realized all of a sudden, I just don’t care anymore. Years and years and years of solitary confinement did it to me. Made me not care, so desensitized. In the hole for 10 years total. Everywhere — total. ... I did not regret coming to jail. It feels like I’m dead sometimes — all the way. If I’m dead inside, there’s no reason to behave. There’s every reason to misbehave. If I act up, I get my way. If I bang my head off the door, till I’m bleeding, they have to come and put me in restraints.”
Ms. Applegate wrote that Dickinson wants to be in isolation and knows he is a danger to any cellmate. “If they give me a cellie, he’s dead. They know it.” Dickinson told Ms. Applegate.
The victim’s mother, Arlene Thompson, wrote a statement about her son, who worked night turn at Myers Well Service driving a water truck, that was read into the record Monday by Assistant District Attorney Chris Stone.
She described her son as a kind person whose smile could light up a room.
"The world would be a happier place if you could see it like Kevin did," she wrote. "Mr. Dickinson has taken something away from me that cannot be replaced."
During the hearing, Judge Mariani spoke in friendly terms with Dickinson, noting that he wrote him letters from the Allegheny County Jail calling the judge his "eminence."
Following the hearing, Judge Mariani called Mr. Thompson's mother and brother to the front of the courtroom to explain why he dealt with Dickinson in the way he did.
"We were dealing with someone very vulnerable," the judge said. His light tone, he continued, was to make sure Dickinson stayed under control.
"Please know that doesn't minimize what happened," he said.
Ms. Thompson thanked him.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.