DETROIT — What really happened between Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner and Detroit police outside a hotel elevator on March 6 was the focus Thursday during the first full day of testimony in her trial.
In their opening statements, and in the questioning of three hotel workers on duty the night of the incident, the two sides laid claim to opposite interpretations of a key one-minute window of time, with Ms. Wagner’s defense arguing she never assaulted the officers and the prosecution claiming she blocked their entry to the hotel elevator and grabbed one of them.
The exchange near the elevator in a Westin hotel as Detroit police attempted to remove Ms. Wagner’s husband, Khari Mosley, from the building after he was accused of causing a disturbance, was the main point of the trial involving Ms. Wagner, who is charged with one felony count of assaulting, resisting and obstructing a police officer, and a misdemeanor count of disturbing the peace.
Ms. Wagner’s attorney argued she had the right to ask questions of the officers as the situation with her husband escalated, culminating in her being “slammed” to the ground and put in a wrist lock.
“You’re not going to see Chelsa Wagner resist arrest,” Detroit attorney Charles Longstreet II, told the jury in his opening statement. “You’re not going to see Chelsa Wagner obstruct the police officers, You’re not going to see her assault a police officer. What you’re going to see at the end of this case is Chelsa Wagner is not guilty of any charge in this case.”
Wayne County Assistant Prosecutor Erika Tusar said she wanted to prove that rules “apply to everyone,” and told the jury multiple times that Ms. Wagner referred to herself during the incident as the “highest elected official in [her] county.” She also claimed Ms. Wagner berated the cops in the squad car after her arrest, calling them “scoundrels,” asking them if they’re smoking crack and saying it’d be the last day they’d ever have badges.
Read More
The officers, the prosecutor said, did as best they could to try to “avoid” the original confrontation, but it ended in Ms. Wagner blocking the elevator, refusing to move when asked and making contact with one of the officers.
“’[The officers] go on, they go past, now she starts grabbing on the officer,” the prosecutor said. “There’s a little tussle that goes on, and [Ms. Wagner] goes down. The officer is going to tell you he tried to break her fall.”
The jury heard testimony from three witnesses for the prosecution, including one who was outside the elevator when the incident occurred: Tim Scott, a security guard, was working the Westin Book Cadillac hotel that night.
Mr. Scott said when police were trying to put Mr. Mosely on the elevator to escort him out of the hotel, Ms. Wagner stood in the way of the entrance. No one was able to pass her, he testified.
As one of the officers squeezed past her to get on the elevator, Ms. Wagner “literally [started] yanking at his arm,” Mr. Scott said.
Ms. Wagner fell to the ground “on her own” in the process of pulling on the officer’s arm, Mr. Scott said, adding that it wasn’t from being shoved.
Mr. Scott’s line of vision to the incident was a point of contention in cross-examination, with Mr. Longstreet asking about his position in the hallway. Mr. Scott said the two Detroit officers were “standing in front” of him near the elevator, but that he could see Ms. Wagner’s “face and body.”
The security guard said he never saw the officers strike or curse at Ms. Wagner or Mr. Mosley.
Facing charges from the same incident, Mr. Mosely was found not guilty in July of disorderly conduct and disturbing the peace — though Ms. Wagner’s defense isn’t permitted to mention that at her trial.
The confrontation began after hotel staffers called 911 on Mr. Mosley, who had become agitated at them for not allowing him a keycard to the couple’s room. The room was in Ms. Wagner’s name.
On Thursday, the prosecution painted Mr. Mosley as argumentative, belligerent and loud, deeming his attempted removal from the hotel as justified because staff had said he could only stay in the couple’s room if he was “quiet” and went to sleep.
The defense acknowledged Mr. Mosley was “a little irritated,” but said it was because he was five hours from home, told to leave with nowhere else to go and falsely accused of assault by the hotel staff.
In Thursday’s testimony, a front desk staffer at the hotel described Mr. Mosley as being “really aggressive” toward him and using profanities — even though hotel policy, in this case, dictated that he wasn’t allowed to have a room key because his name wasn’t on the reservation.
On Thursday, the staffer testified that Mr. Mosley threatened him that night. But on cross-examination, Mr. Longstreet cited a written statement taken from the staffer a few days after the incident, where he indicated he didn’t remember if Mr. Mosley had threatened him.
The prosecution countered that the question prompting the written statement wasn’t if Mr. Mosley threatened him, but “how” he threatened him. Asked what he remembers Mr. Mosely saying that night, the staffer recounted a profanity-laden diatribe that included, “I’ll [expletive] you guys up. Give me the [expletive] key.”
The eventual confrontation at the elevator occurred after police left Mr. Mosley in the couple’s room.
Mr. Scott said after the couple closed the door to their room, he had gotten about 10-to-15 feet down the hallway with the officers when they heard “what sounded like ... kicking or pounding” on the door from inside, so they returned.
Asked on cross if he had investigated to see if there was any damage to the room when he returned with Mr. Mosley later to allow him to retrieve the couple’s belongings, Mr. Scott said he never looked.
The trial will continue Monday. It was delayed because of complications over jury selection earlier this week. The selection of the 12-member jury and two alternates concluded early Thursday.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.