When news of the Tree of Life massacre broke, Kathleen M. Carley was in Spain, at an academic conference on the power of social media, and all of the sudden her peers were asking a question she couldn’t answer.

“All of my colleagues were like, ‘What is wrong with America?’”

The price we pay for our national penchant for violence really hit home a little later, when Ms. Carley — director of CMU’s Center for Informed Democracy and Social Cyber Security — saw the victim list. It included a friend, Joyce Fienberg, 75, a former University of Pittsburgh researcher.

That news reinforced Professor Carley’s commitment to understanding online radicalization.

Advertise with us

Experts agree that while Tree of Life was America’s worst anti-Semitic incident, and while we have seen more and more mass shootings, hate and violence are woven through our history — and the world’s. Some, though, detect a new tide of alienation and nihilism, at a time when social media makes incitement easier than ever, and powerful guns are plentiful.

The road to a healthier America isn’t entirely clear, but experts are looking for big and small ways to turn down the hate.

For now, we live with what James Densley of Metropolitan State University in Minneapolis, calls “a low-level anxiety that we experience now when we go into a public space — an expectation that something terrible could happen, and that’s not a good way to be living our lives.”

The vast pool of the disillusioned

According to Mr. Densley, who is with the university’s Violence Project, ever since Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold went on a rampage at Columbine High School in 1999, many Americans have felt as if we’ve been stuck in a bad movie genre.

Advertise with us

The script: Shooters devise their plans and carry out their evil deeds, followed by media spectacle that may only encourage copycats, followed by thoughts and prayers from politicians and futile debates over gun control and mental illness.

Now, there is even merchandise to go with profound social anxiety: bulletproof backpacks for back-to-school.

In 2019, 58 people have died in nine mass shootings, two of the worst happening on the same August weekend, in Texas and Ohio.

“Some of them are far-right terrorists, some of them are not,” said Mary Beth Altier, a professor at New York University’s Center for Global Affairs who studies political extremism. So far, the public appears to be focused on curbing mass shootings, rather than addressing the extremism that drives some of the deadliest incidents, she said.

Mr. Densley, with psychologist Jillian Peterson, founded The Violence Project in 2017 to create a database, funded by the U.S. Department of Justice, that contains every mass shooting since 1966. “What we’re trying to do is dive a little deeper and look at the psychosocial histories of these mass shooters,” he said. They have established 50 different variables for the 160 shootings.

Advertise with us

While there’s no one profile of a mass shooter, they have identified four common traits:

• Exposure to trauma or violence at a young age;

• anger triggered by a recent “crisis point”;

• a fascination with previous shooters;

• and the means and access to carry out the attack.

Advertise with us

Robert Bowers, the 47-year-old from Baldwin Borough who is charged with killing 11 people and injuring six others at Tree of Life Synagogue last Oct. 27, checked off at least three of those boxes.

In 1979, when he was 7, his father, Randall Bowers, committed suicide while facing charges of an attempted rape. In recent years, Robert Bowers had cut off old friends and had been engaging in anti-immigrant and anti-Semitic conspiracy theories on social media site Gab.com.

“One theory is that Bowers felt closed out” from the political system, said Ms. Altier. “Maybe he had expectations for Trump” but then “became deeply disillusioned about what was happening or not happening, and then he saw violence as the answer.”

The well-armed Tree of Life shooter appears to have emerged from a vast pool of disillusioned white men.

Conspiracy not conservatism

Advertise with us

When Jennifer M. Silva, an Indiana University Bloomington professor who wrote “We’re Still Here: Pain and Politics in the Heart of America,” embedded in the central Pennsylvania coal fields in 2015 and 2016, she expected to meet conservatives. She was surprised to find many conspiracy theorists.

“I think it was kind of a major sense of betrayal and disappointment in social institutions” including churches, unions, employers and political parties, said Ms. Silva.

“[We have] a low-level anxiety that we experience now when we go into a public space, an expectation that something terrible could happen, and that’s not a good way to be living our lives.”

She also found that white nationalism appeals to some working-class white men, particularly younger working class men.

“They wanted to embody this masculine identity of hard work, family provider, toughness. But they didn't have a lot of avenues for doing that,” she said. “Whiteness and their historical roots of being white started to matter for them. … They believed there would be a civil war coming where blacks and Hispanics would battle white people in the streets.”

Short of that nightmare scenario, they were left with a muddle of frustration, aimlessness and, in a service economy, fewer opportunities for the kind of meaningful work that was available to generations before them.

Advertise with us

“We have a script in our culture for how we feel that men should respond to their problems,” Mr. Densley said. “If they don’t have appropriate coping mechanisms, the strain and frustration that men feel — whether it’s related to family life or the economy or education — can turn into anger and we know that anger mobilizes people to action.”

From time immemorial, people have become violent extremists when the quest for personal significance leads them to ideologies that justify violence, and then when they join groups that spur them to act, according to Arie Kruglanski, a psychology professor at the University of Maryland who specializes in the motivations behind radicalization.

Today, some white males in particular feel “significance loss,” he wrote, in response to questions. “The unprecedented wave of immigration, the unprecedented number of displaced persons (above 65 million world wide), create a sense of threat,” he wrote. “Poor white persons whose only claim to significance is their whiteness feel that even that will no longer constitute a claim to respect as they are being invaded by people of color and different culture and religion, so the loss of significance renders masses of people who feel left out and threatened vulnerable to radicalizing narratives and this is exploited by power-hungry politicians.”

Recognizing that crisis, the Baltimore-based Natalie Wynn launched her YouTube channel Contrapoints three years ago in an attempt to confront disillusioned men and de-radicalize members of the extreme alt-right movement.

Redirection and deradicalization

Advertise with us

Working man’s alienation isn’t new. In 1941, psychologist Erich Fromm wrote: “The individual’s feeling of powerless and aloneness has increased, his ‘freedom’ from all traditional bonds has become more pronounced, his possibilities for individual economic achievement have narrowed down.”

That was published at fascism’s high-water mark, but long before the invention of the AR-15 — the tool of choice for many mass shooters, and part of Mr. Bowers’ arsenal, according to the indictment against him. It also long preceded the internet, which some experts see as a common bridge between hateful thought and action.

Light shines from within the sanctuary out through the stained-glass windows of the Tree of Life synagogue, Tuesday, Feb. 19, 2019, in Squirrel Hill. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

People veering toward the fringes “can go online, make connections, discuss topics and share ideas,” said John Pulcastro, an FBI supervisory intelligence analyst at the bureau’s Pittsburgh office, who has worked the extremist beat for 20 years. “They can also be radicalized and mobilized online.”

Because you can find almost anything on the internet, you can always find people to affirm your worst instincts.

“The confirmation bias that occurs when we go on the internet is that there’s a sense that everyone feels the same way I do,” Mr. Densley said. “When we go on social media and get 10 likes for something we posted, we all of a sudden think, ‘Wow, everyone agrees with me!’ Then you take a step back and say, ‘It was 10 people. I could fit them in my living room.’ So there’s this weird thing that happens online where if there’s a few people talking in a chat room, it can really feel like everybody feels that way.”

Advertise with us

Back to old school

So, how does society write a new script?

The FBI — in addition to investigating many tips that bias-based ideologies have led someone to commit a potential federal crime that could lead to violence — has doubled down on “old school” efforts to educate the public on the signs of extremism, and to intervene personally to talk down people who appear to be veering toward radical acts, said Mr. Pulcastro.

“Prosecution is one tool,” but not the preferred one, he said. “Sometimes it’s an interview. Sometimes it’s getting together with a kid and talking about these things, with the parents present.” The bureau is trying to teach parents, coaches, teachers and other people of influence to recognize the signs of extremism and to “talk to people about their grievance narrative in a positive, productive way that sometimes casts doubt” on the roots of violent thought.

Some believe that just as the internet has worsened the problem, technology may be part of the answer. Ms. Carley, for example, is part of a small community of CMU researchers working on ways to curb the spread of hate online.

Advertise with us

In the months prior to the Tree of Life massacre, several big online platforms implemented policies aimed at reducing vitriol. Facebook rolled out “community standards,” Twitter started banning “dehumanizing speech,” and Reddit started “quarantining” subreddits judged “highly offensive or upsetting.”

Finding hate groups to latch onto will soon be harder than it was a few years ago. Facebook, Twitter, Google, Microsoft and Amazon have teamed up to fight the spread of extremist content online, and Facebook has banned more than 200 white supremacist organizations from its platform.

The social media company is also working with organizations like ExitUSA and MoonshotCVE to disrupt and redirect users searching for violent extremist content.

Ludovica Di Giorgi of MoonshotCVE was recently in Pittsburgh for a convention on Homeland Security. He explained that the company “uses the same tools that commercial companies use to connect with potential customers and redirect them to the products they’re selling.”

A user who praises or expresses interest in joining an extremist group, or, for instance, tries to download the white supremacist video game Ethnic Cleansing, may instead get “a YouTube playlist that connects them to safe, positive alternatives that ultimately debunk the main narratives that extremist groups [use] to radicalize and recruit.”

Advertise with us

Or they might get an ad linking them to Life After Hate, a nonprofit founded by former white supremacist Arno Michaelis, who has been in Pittsburgh to speak a number of times since the Tree of Life shooting. Life After Hate — which was funded by a grant from the Obama administration and defunded by the Trump administration, but able to continue crowdfunding — works one-on-one to deradicalize white supremacists and has spoken to thousands of kids since 2011.

Is education the remedy?

Mr. Densley of the Violence Project believes that we need to start in the schools, teaching kids how to be critical consumers of what they discover online. He’s skeptical about measures like lockdown drills, which might save lives in the still-statistically-uncommon event of a school shooting, but might do broad harm by giving kids the sense that sudden attacks are a normal part of life, or even spurring a fascination with mass violence.

For most kids, such drills “will just become background noise,” he said. “But for some kids who perhaps have had childhood trauma and are perhaps experiencing a crisis point in their lives, then this might trigger a fascination.”

One of the goals of The Violence Project is to shift the notions of threat assessment for kids in schools and people in the workplace.

Advertise with us

“We recognize that any threat is really a cry for help and in many ways any threat is a suicide note because if you’re threatening to perpetrate a mass shooting, you’re essentially saying, ‘I don’t care if I live or die,’” he said.

Despite responses from government, the tech sector and society as a whole, scholars agree that extremism was gaining momentum long before Tree of Life, and continues to spread.

“You can try to take down their forums and ban their accounts and de-platform their events, but as long as this male identity crisis goes on, I don’t see any end to these problems,” said Ms. Wynn.

Society is just beginning to respond to a tide that has been rising for years, said Peter Simi, author of “American Swastika: Inside the White Power Movement’s Hidden Spaces of Hate.

“Let’s not pretend that we’re not way behind,” he said. “We’ve got a lot of catching up to do.”

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com. Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542.