A man who displayed the severed head of his common law wife to police when they came to his house for a domestic disturbance must keep serving a life prison sentence, a state appeals court has ruled.

That is so even though Melvin White claimed his brain wasn’t fully developed when he committed the murder 40 years ago in front of his kids, the Superior Court judges found.

White was 23 when the slaying occurred in Philadelphia. In an opinion by Judge Paula Franciso Ott, the state court rejected White’s argument that he should be resentenced, and possibly even freed, under a 2012 U.S. Supreme Court ruling that bars automatic life sentences for juvenile killers.

That federal ruling, the Miller v Alabama decision, applies only to those who were younger than 18 when they killed, Judge Ott noted. The Miller decision was based in part on scientific research that showed the brains of juveniles are not as fully developed as those of adults.

Advertise with us

Judge Ott cited another ruling her court made in an unrelated homicide case earlier this year that reinforced the age 18 cut-off for Miller-based appeals. In that case, the judges denied the appeal of a woman who claimed the Miller ruling should have been applied in her case because she was 18 years and 9 months old when she participated in a fatal robbery.

Judge Ott also found that White’s appeal, the latest in a series he has filed over the last few decades, was not timely. White, now 63, was sentenced to life behind bars after a Philly jury convicted him of first-degree murder in 1983.

In a federal appeal that was dismissed in 2003, Judge Norma L. Shapiro described the scenario of White’s crime.

Judge Shapiro wrote that White demanded that police leave his home when they answered a disturbance call in the early afternoon of Oct. 20, 1979. Then, she wrote, the officers heard “chopping noises.”

“A short time later, White walked down the stairs naked with the severed head of the mother of one of his children,” the federal judge wrote.

Advertise with us

Police said White had ordered another man, Gregory Tarkenton, to behead the woman when she came to the house to pick up her child. They said they found Tarkenton and two young children on the second floor of White’s house, staring at the victim’s headless corpse.

White gave a written confession, saying he ordered Tarkenton to behead the woman because he didn’t want her to take her child, Judge Shapiro noted.

Tarkenton also is serving a life prison term, court records show.