The board that runs the Northern Regional Police Department will enter into a $175,000 settlement of a federal lawsuit brought by a woman who was erroneously identified as an illegal immigrant and jailed overnight, the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania announced Tuesday.
The settlement appears to end litigation related to the 2011 arrest of Angelica Davila, then 26 and living in West Mifflin, who immigrated to America from Mexico at age 2. By 2011 she was a permanent resident who had applied for citizenship and was working at an Olive Garden restaurant.
Northern Regional police pulled her over for driving without headlights on as she left a Mexican grocery in Pine with a Honduran friend who was not legally in the U.S. The officer called Immigration and Customs Enforcement, according to the complaint she and the ACLU later filed, and ICE issued detainers asking the officer to hold both of them. They were taken to the Allegheny County Jail, and Ms. Davila was released the next day.
Detainers are requests from law enforcement to keep a person in custody.
“I didn’t understand why the officer arrested me and took me to jail,” said Ms. Davila, now of McAllen, Texas, according to a press release by the ACLU, which represented her. “It was only after filing a right to know request that I learned ICE had made a mistake about my immigration status. I filed this case because I don’t want this to happen to anyone else.”
“We hope this case will dissuade local police departments from cooperating with ICE’s requests to arrest people for alleged immigration violations,” said Reggie Shuford, executive director of the ACLU of Pennsylvania, in the release.
Read More
An ICE spokesman wrote in response to questions that the agency issues detainers when it has probable cause to believe an alien is removable from the country. Detainers allow the law enforcement agency holding the person to keep them in custody for as long as 48 hours, so ICE can come for them.
Failure to honor a detainer, according to the ICE spokesman, can harm public safety when "individuals, who often have significant criminal histories, are released onto the street, presenting a potential public safety threat," and compelling the federal agency to attempt arrests "in neighborhoods and workplaces" rather than just taking custody from a jail.
In February, Chief U.S. District Judge Mark R. Hornak ruled that Ms. Davila’s case against Northern Regional could continue to trial, setting the stage for the settlement.
Mr. Shuford called the case “a warning to police departments to stay out of federal immigration enforcement.”
Run by the Northern Regional Joint Police Board, the department polices Pine, Richland. Marshall and Bradford Woods. Northern Regional Chief T. Robert Amann declined comment on the settlement.
Ms. Davila in 2015 settled with Allegheny County, which paid $25,000 and agreed to stop using its jail to hold people on federal immigration detainers without a judge’s order.
The jail has, since 2016, received 127 requests from ICE — involving 27 alleged Mexican nationals, 19 Hondurans, 10 Guatemalans and smaller numbers from Asian, African and other Latin American countries. It has not responded to ICE, according to a county response to a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette records request.
Ms. Davila also sued the federal government, settling in 2018 for $12,500.
The ACLU alleged that Ms. Davila's arrest violated her Fourth Amendment rights against unlawful search and seizure. The civil rights group alleges that ICE "routinely issues detainers simply because it wants more time to investigate a person’s immigration status" and does so "without any authorization or oversight by a judge."
The ACLU in June sued state police, alleging that they unlawfully held 10 Latin American motorists in five separate incidents while investigating their immigration status. That case is pending in the U.S. Middle District Court of Pennsylvania.
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.