Family reacts to the verdict against Derrick Gallaway
A jury deliberated for just over two hours Tuesday before finding a California man guilty of first-degree murder in the 2016 shooting death of a Jefferson Hills motel owner.
Derrick Gallaway, 63, now faces a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole for killing Dehnad “Danny” Taiedi.
The jury of nine women and three men also found Mr. Gallaway guilty of robbery, theft and tampering with evidence following a trial that began one week earlier.
Police said Mr. Gallaway killed the 78-year-old owner of the Jefferson Hills Motel on Route 51 while the victim worked the overnight shift May 27, 2016.
Mr. Gallaway did not visibly react as the verdict was read in the courtroom of Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Mark V. Tranquilli.
Kimberly Taiedi Francis, the victim's daughter, said she worried during the trial that she might not get the closure she wanted, but then realized that whatever the verdict, her dad was gone.
Read More
"It matters, yes, if justice is served. But whatever the verdict, I am forever changed. Nothing brings my dad back. I have forever branded in my memory the phone call on May 27, 2016. In one second, my world was changed forever."
"It doesn't bring him back, but Derrick Gallaway will not be on the streets to hurt anyone else," said Ashley Nebel, Mr. Taiedi's granddaughter.
"The chief was a good man, and no one will forget him," said his stepdaughter, Carrie Simpson.
She said she is glad Mr. Gallaway will go to prison.
"It's good to know he'll just be put away, and we can forget about him and not forget about the chief and remember him. It should be that way.'
In closing arguments Tuesday morning, the prosecutor said that for Mr. Gallaway to be found innocent, almost every single prosecution witness had to be lying.
That would include: The employees of the Jefferson Hills Motel who testified that Mr. Gallaway had stayed there several times — sometimes for long periods of time; a woman who was staying at the motel the night of May 26, 2016, and said she heard Mr. Gallaway and another man talk about robbing the place; and even a borough police officer who said he interacted with Mr. Gallaway at the motel a year before the shooting.
"Everybody is lying except him," Chief Trial Deputy District Attorney Daniel Fitzsimmons told the jury.
Mr. Fitzsimmons told the jury that the prosecution believes Mr. Gallaway shot Mr. Taiedi. But, whether acting alone or with someone else, Mr. Fitzimmons said that Mr. Gallaway plotted to rob Mr. Taiedi, and the victim was killed during that robbery, which would be second-degree murder.
“If he was a partner in the robbery itself, he is as guilty as if he, himself, had the gun in his hand and pulled the trigger,” Mr. Fitzsimmons said.
The motel cash box was empty, and there was debris all over the office.
Crime scene investigators found Mr. Gallaway's blood inside the office and in the motel parking lot.
On Friday, the defendant told the jury that he had been in a car with a prostitute in the motel parking lot when he heard the shots from inside the office.
He said he cut his hand on the woman's crack pipe and didn't realize it was bleeding when he went into the motel to check what had happened.
Mr. Gallaway told the jury he wanted to call the police, but couldn't find a cell phone to use — and didn't want to use the office phone in case it would implicate him.
During his closing argument, Mr. Fitzsimmons urged the jury to consider what each witness had to gain through their testimony.
“Do they have an interest in the outcome of the case? Do they have anything to gain or lose?” the prosecutor asked.
Mr. Gallaway did, he continued.
“How might that taint every single word he told you on Friday?” Mr. Fitzsimmons asked.
He called the DNA from the blood at the scene “the most probative identifying evidence.”
But during his closing argument, defense attorney Elbert Gray Jr. told the jury that his client bled walking into the crime scene — not walking out.
"DNA does not kill anybody," Mr. Gray said. "The fact that Mr. Gallaway's DNA was there doesn't prove anything."
Mr. Fitzsimmons, questioned, however, why Mr. Gallaway’s blood was not on the exterior handle of the office door, but was found on the interior handle.
He emphasized to the jury, too, that Mr. Gallaway could not explain his blood being present on the inside of the tray of the motel cash box.
"He's had a long time to think about it and explain away the evidence," the prosecutor said. "He didn't even try to explain how this happened."
Mr. Gray, however, dismissed the blood evidence from the cash box, noting that scientists from the Allegheny County crime lab could not get a positive DNA match from it.
Instead, the prosecution called an expert in probabilistic genotyping who said it was 24.6 quadrillion times more likely the blood belonged to Mr. Gallaway than a coincidental match to an unrelated African American.
"These aren't scientists," Mr. Gray said. "They're mathematicians."
As for the rest of the prosecution's case, the defense said there were no fingerprints linking Mr. Gallaway to the crime or eyewitnesses that saw the shooting.
"My question to you at this point is: Have they done enough to prove to you, beyond a reasonable doubt, that what they said is true? Have they done enough to prove to you Derrick Gallaway shot and killed Danny Taiedi?" Mr. Gray asked at the beginning of his closing.
"They simply haven't done enough," he concluded.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.