Police say a man fatally stabbed a Tarentum woman while in her apartment Friday night, hid the knife behind a couch and then told investigators shifting stories about her death.
Eventually, police said, Juan H. Hayden, 55, admitted to stabbing Susan E. Jeffries, 54.
Hayden was charged with homicide and tampering with evidence. He was arraigned Saturday evening at the Allegheny County Jail, where he was being held without bond.
Hayden, who lives several blocks from the apartment where the stabbing occurred in the 600 block of East Ninth Avenue, told police that Jeffries "had come at him" because he questioned her about having another man in her apartment, according to a criminal complaint.
"Hayden said that he stabbed her in the chest," the complaint said. "Hayden stated that when Jeffries came at him, he was holding a dinner plate in one hand and a knife in the other, when he stabbed her."
The complaint did not indicate the nature of the relationship between the defendant and Ms. Jeffries.
Police responded to Ms. Jeffries' apartment Friday around 9:34 p.m. after Hayden called 911 from what he said was the victim's cell phone.
Officers found Ms. Jeffries on the kitchen floor; she was taken to Allegheny General Hospital, where she died of a stab wound to the abdomen just before 11 p.m.
Ms. Jeffries' neck was bruised and she had a deep stab wound to her torso, the complaint said.
Hayden, who was at Ms. Jeffries' apartment when police arrived, at first told authorities that he was not in the apartment when she was stabbed.
He told detectives that Ms. Jeffries had left the apartment and returned with a man, whom he described to police.
It was unclear from the police paperwork if such a man existed.
Hayden said that he left and came back to find Ms. Jeffries on the ground with a stab wound, the complaint said.
Hayden told police that he applied pressure, and that Ms. Jeffries scratched him.
But when police challenged Hayden's story, letting him know they had found a bloody knife and reminding him that he had indicated on the 911 call that he was in the apartment when the stabbing occurred, his story changed, the complaint said.
Tarentum police saw human hairs and stains on Hayden's shirt while he was being taken to their police station, according to the complaint. And detectives noted that he had scratches on his arms and hands, the complaint said.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.