Karen Vechter was a trusted employee, having joined the Braff Group nearly 18 years earlier.

The North Irwin woman was responsible for the Mt. Lebanon mergers and acquisitions advisory firm’s payroll, human resources management and book-keeping. She paid the bills, handled the bank accounts and kept track of credit card statements.

And she stole $286,000.

On Tuesday, Vechter, 59, pleaded guilty to theft, forgery and access device fraud.

Advertise with us

She will serve 16 months house arrest to be followed by four years probation. As part of the plea agreement, Vechter also paid back the full restitution amount with a check at the hearing.

Still, the owner of the company, Dexter Braff, was not satisfied. Instead, he believed that Vechter should have gone to jail, and told Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski he was disenchanted by a system that allows white-collar criminals to often avoid incarceration.

She "found a way to profit from her despicable behavior,” he said in his victim-impact statement.

"So, Your Honor, unless you decide to reject the plea agreement, I can only conclude that crime does pay," Mr. Braff said. "That if you're a female, in her 60s, not in the best of health, with only a DUI on her record, the court will treat the theft of more than $250,000 as merely a 'white' collar crime.

“But if [a] defendant appeared before the bench having stolen $250,000 from a safe in our office, jail time would surely be forthcoming."

Advertise with us

Judge Borkowski was sympathetic to Mr. Braff and acknowledged the betrayal the victim felt. But he also said that the repayment of the money taken was a good outcome.

“It’s very, very unusual that restitution in that amount is ever made, let alone in a one-time payment,” the judge said.

According to the criminal complaint, Vechter, since 2001, had used the company’s American Express card — and later a Citizens Bank debit card — to pay for her own personal expenses.

Among the items she paid for were delinquent school taxes and household expenses like cable and phone bills, clothes, life insurance and groceries, the complaint said. But the investigation also showed Vechter paid for trips to the Grand Canyon, the Caribbean and for an Alaskan cruise.

She spent nearly $6,000 on a diamond tennis bracelet from QVC and additional jewelry purchases from Louis Anthony Jewelers and Jared.

Advertise with us

Mr. Braff learned of the theft when Citizens Bank contacted him in October 2017 about a Mastercard account the bank said he was attempting to open. Mr. Braff told the bank he was unaware of it and had not given permission for one to be opened. He then asked two of his employees to review the company's bank records; they found unusual cash withdrawals and purchases on the company debit card.

Mr. Braff fired Vechter on Oct. 13, 2017 after he confronted her about the theft.

Although prosecutors believe Vechter’s criminal activity began in 2001, they charged her with crimes dating back only to 2011 because earlier bank records were unavailable.

Vechter did not make any statement during the court hearing.

But in Mr. Braff’s testimony, he told the court that for years he believed her to be honest and that he trusted Vechter implicitly "with the millions of dollars of company funds that she had unfettered access to in order to manage the day-to-day operations of the firm."

Advertise with us

Mr. Braff said that, over the course of her employment, Vechter earned more than $2 million in salary and bonuses and in 2017 had received a $21,000 bonus.

The money she stole, Mr. Braff said, would have otherwise gone to other employees — either in the form of raises or bonuses.

He noted, too, that Vechter was often seen as generous — giving lavish gifts to Mr. Braff's children — even though the money she used was actually stolen.

The last words Vechter said to Mr. Braff when he fired her, he told the judge, were “ ’I’m a good person.’ ”

Mr. Braff told her in court that was not true.

Advertise with us

"You are a thief. You are a liar — to me, your co-workers, your friends, your family, and perhaps the most hurtful, to my children, who loved you, and were brought to tears when they learned your friendly demeanor was just a cover for your theft,” Mr. Braff said.

He called her selfish, greedy and callous.

"So, no, Karen, you are not a good person. What you are is a felon. And that will be your legacy."

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.