A Washington County man serving 12-and-a-half years in federal prison for sharing child porn showing toddlers being forced to have sex with animals and other sadistic images saw his sentence cut Monday by more than two years because of an appellate decision.

U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose re-sentenced Christopher Welshans, 42, of rural Smith Township, to 121 months, after which his angry family denounced the judge and the government and U.S. marshals escorted them from the building.

Welshans, who had claimed that state agents had planted child porn on his computer because of his anti-government views, was one of the few child porn defendants to go to trial in this district. Almost all plead guilty.

He was quickly convicted in 2016 of possession and distribution following an investigation begun by the state attorney general’s office.

Advertise with us

He had been targeted in 2014 by state agents investigating porn sharing on the BitTorrent network. His aunt said he brought his laptop to her house in Burgettstown to use her internet service because he didn't have service at home in the village of Atlasburg, where he lived with his mother.

Agents and police raided both houses in March 2014 and recovered more than 10,000 child porn files and hundreds of videos on Welshans’ computer at the Atlasburg address.

Law officers said he was initially combative but later talked, insisting he was a “citizen of nowhere” who does not recognize the U.S. court system. He also said agents planted the child porn on his computer because of his stance against the government.

He appealed his original sentence on the grounds that prosecutors improperly introduced “inflammatory” details about the nature of the porn involved and also that the judge erred in enhancing his sentence because he had tried to delete the images after his aunt warned him that police were on the way.

A three-judge panel of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with Welshans that the prosecution’s closing argument “improperly appealed to the passions of the jury” by describing the worst of the porn but that it didn’t matter because the trial was fair and the evidence overwhelming.

Advertise with us

On the second issue, two judges on the panel, L. Felipe Restrepo and Thomas Ambro, said Judge Ambrose was wrong to enhance the sentence on an obstruction of justice claim because Welshans set his laptop to delete the porn files automatically when he learned police were coming and then hid the laptop between couch cushions.

Judge Julio Fuentes disagreed and said she was right because Welshans was trying to hide evidence.

The majority judges said that for an enhancement to apply, the actions had to have hindered the investigation. The judges said agents were quickly able to restore the images, so Welshans’ attempt didn't hinder them.

In imposing the new sentence, Judge Ambrose took into account Welshans’ autism, his role as a caretaker for his father and other relatives and the fact that he has worked and sought education while in prison.

But she also noted that Welshans knew he was wrong to collect the porn because he tried to hide the evidence. She said that child porn is a “plague on our society” to which Welshans contributed.

“I do believe you are a risk,” she said. “These children are victimized over and over.”