ELYRIA, Ohio — A judge has cut nearly in half the damages awarded to a bakery that won a defamation lawsuit against Oberlin College.

A jury originally awarded David Gibson, Allyn W. Gibson, and Gibson Bros. Inc. $44.2 million in punitive and compensatory damages from Oberlin in a case that involved student-led protests and boycotts that labeled the family’s business as racially biased following the arrest of black students in a shoplifting case.

But on Thursday, Lorain County Common Pleas Judge John Miraldi ruled the three parties will receive only $25 million from Oberlin, according to court records. Citing Ohio law, Judge Miraldi said punitive damages must be capped at twice the sum of compensatory damages.

Specifically, Judge Miraldi awarded $14 million in total damages to David Gibson, including $11.6 million in punitive damages, $1.8 million in economic damages, and $600,000 in noneconomic damages. Mr. Gibson was originally awarded $17.5 million in punitive damages by the jury.

Advertise with us

Allyn W. Gibson — the patriarch of the family — was awarded a total of $6.5 million; he originally was awarded $11.75 million.

Gibson Bros. Inc., the group that operates Gibson’s Food Mart and Bakery near the college, was awarded $4.549 million. That figure includes just over $2.2 million for economic loss and another $2.2 million in punitive damages.

Oberlin College filed a motion June 21 to cap compensatory and punitive damages based on precedent and the Ohio law. Lawyers argued that the plaintiffs’ noneconomic damages should be capped at three times the economic damages, or a maximum of $350,000 per plaintiff.

Similarly, they argued punitive damages must be capped at twice the amount of compensatory damages.

Attorneys for the bakery argued the Gibsons asserted multiple claims for relief (libel and intentional infliction of emotional distress), and the damages should have been applied to each claim, not to combined claims.

Advertise with us

The lawsuit stems from an incident Nov. 9, 2016, in which a black Oberlin student tried to “steal or otherwise illegally obtain” wine from Gibson’s, according to the complaint. A son of David Gibson, also named Allyn Gibson, pursued and “engaged in a physical altercation” with the student, according to the court’s summary judgment. The student and two friends were arrested. The students involved are black; Allyn Gibson is white.

After the arrests, student protests erupted, with participants claiming the criminal charges and physical conflict were racially motivated, and protesters urged patrons to shop elsewhere.

The jury in the case found Oberlin and college officials promoted and aided the students’ efforts.

The students pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge in August 2017, reading statements into the record that Mr. Gibson was within his rights to detain the robber and that the conflict was not racially motivated.

The Block News Alliance consists of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, The Blade of Toledo, Ohio, and television station WDRB in Louisville, Ky. Jay Skebba is a reporter for The Blade.