The defense attorney for an Indiana County man accused of killing two people when he drove under the influence of drugs in Plum two years ago said Wednesday that his client's actions did not cause the victims' deaths.

"If they had their seat belts on, they probably wouldn't have died," said Patrick Thomassey.

That, he argued to Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman, means that his client, Edward Cass III, 27, of Saltsburg, should be found not guilty of homicide by vehicle while DUI.

Mr. Cass is charged in the crash that killed Beth Ann Beveridge, 43, and rear-seat passenger, Michael Zier, 17, both of Tarentum.

Advertise with us

Judge Cashman will render a verdict in the case. If Mr. Cass is convicted of the homicide by vehicle while DUI charge, he faces a mandatory penalty of three to six years in prison for each victim.

Ms. Beveridge was driving outbound on Golden Mile Highway/Route 286 in Plum about 10 p.m. on Aug. 6, 2017, near Pine Valley Plaza. Mr. Cass was driving in-bound when his Toyota sedan crossed the center line and struck her Hyundai Santa Fe head-on.

Neither of the two victims wore their seat belts, and a detective from Allegheny County said that Ms. Beveridge’s seat belt was buckled behind her.

A manager from the medical examiner's crime lab testified during the non-jury trial that Mr. Cass had a lethal level of fentanyl in his blood, and that he had smoked marijuana close in time to the crash.

Evidence showed that Mr. Cass' vehicle traveled in Ms. Beveridge's lane for 300 to 400 feet prior to the crash, the detective said.

Advertise with us

To prove homicide by vehicle while DUI, Mr. Thomassey said, the prosecution must show that Mr. Cass' crossing the highway is what caused the deaths. If there's an intervening cause — the victims not wearing a seat belt — his client should be found not guilty, the defense attorney said.

"If you use the but-for analysis, would they be dead?" Mr. Thomassey asked.

But Deputy District Attorney Kevin Chernosky told Judge Cashman that Pennsylvania statute and case law preclude Mr. Thomassey from making that argument.

Under Pennsylvania law, violations of the seat belt law “are not admissible as evidence in a criminal proceeding except in a proceeding for a violation of [that law].”

And, a 1993 state Superior Court case upheld a lower court decision that precluded a defendant from arguing the victim in his fatal crash contributed to her death by failing to wear a seat belt.

Advertise with us

Mr. Chernosky argued the crash was caused by Mr. Cass having used fentanyl and marijuana and the combined effect of the two drugs on him.

Not only did Mr. Cass depart from his lane of travel, he was so far over that the driver’s side tires of his car were over the fog line in Ms. Beveridge’s lane, the prosecutor said.

If Mr. Cass wasn’t intoxicated, “We’re not talking about two dead people. We’re talking about two people that never would have crossed paths.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.