The Pennsylvania Attorney General’s office has taken over the criminal prosecution of suspended Aliquippa police Assistant Chief Joseph Perciavalle III. In doing so, the office on last Thursday refiled two felony charges against him in the wake of revelations that he brought allegations of police misconduct to the Beaver County district attorney in 2016.

Those 2016 interactions may play a key part in Assistant Chief Perciavalle’s defense in at least one of the two criminal cases brought against him, his attorney, Steven Townsend said Wednesday. Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier could be called as a defense witness, he said.

That, both sides agreed, meant Mr. Lozier should remove his office from the case and hand it over to state prosecutors. The attorney general’s office, which declined to comment, took over both cases in late March, according to court records.

“There is some part of the case [where] they think I may be a witness, so to avoid any appearance of conflict we referred it to the attorney general,” Mr. Lozier said Wednesday.

Advertise with us

Screenshots of text messages between Assistant Chief Perciavalle and Mr. Lozier that were included in a court filing show that the pair made plans to meet and exchange information more than once in 2016, and an email shows that some allegations of police corruption and illegal gambling were referred to the attorney general’s office in January 2016.

That could end up being crucial evidence for the defense, Mr. Townsend said.

Assistant Chief Perciavalle, 44, of Aliquippa, faces charges in two separate criminal cases. In one, he is accused of texting a sexually explicit video to the 17-year-old daughter of another police officer, and in the other, he is accused of secretly recording a conversation with now suspended police Chief Don Couch.

Both the explicit video and the audio recording were discovered as authorities investigated the death of Rachael DelTondo, 33, who was shot to death in her driveway on May 13, 2018. Assistant Chief Perciavalle sent the explicit video, which showed a woman urinating while swinging in a park, to then 17-year-old Lauren Watkins, who was one of the last people to see Ms. DelTondo alive, as well as to her father, Aliquippa police Sgt. Kenneth Watkins, and his wife.

Assistant Chief Perciavalle was charged with two felonies and a misdemeanor in that case, but the two felony counts were dismissed at a December preliminary hearing. The AG’s office refiled those charges last Thursday and is also prosecuting the charge that was held for court.

Advertise with us

Assistant Chief Perciavalle was also charged with a felony in a separate case in which he is accused of secretly recording a conversation with then Chief Don Couch on March 2, 2018, the same day that state police executed a search warrant on Aliquippa city offices in connection to a grand jury investigation.

It is illegal in Pennsylvania to secretly record a private conversation, with a handful of exceptions. One exception, Mr. Townsend said, is if a person fears a “crime of violence” is about to occur.

Mr. Townsend said Wednesday that Assistant Chief Perciavalle had a legitimate fear of violence because he’d met with Mr. Lozier and provided information regarding police misconduct, and that Chief Couch could have been implicated.

“I’m pretty sure Couch thought he might get in a jam ... so I believe Couch knew Joe was cooperating and was trying to intimidate him into keeping his mouth shut,” Mr. Townsend said.

Chief Couch, who could not be reached Wednesday, previously testified that he was not sure what Assistant Chief Perciavalle knew or who he’d talked to when they had the recorded conversation, and said he would not have tried to stop the assistant chief from cooperating with an outside investigation.

Advertise with us

The chief was suspended with pay for undisclosed reasons in June 2018 and an acting chief now heads the department.

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.