A Westmoreland County car salesman fatally struck an 86-year-old man last month with a company car and then drove away, tried to cover up evidence of the crime and returned with the vehicle to his dealership, police said in a criminal complaint.
Jonathan A. McElroy, 42, of Mount Pleasant was charged Wednesday in the death of Clarence “Fritz” Wolff of Greensburg.
“It’s hard to say whether or not we’re happy that they found him, but we’re definitely relieved by it, just to know that this guy will have justice served and to know he’s not walking around the town enjoying life,” Mr. Wolff’s granddaughter, Lauren Gerritsen, of Buffalo, N.Y., said Thursday.
Mr. Wolff was struck April 19 around 7:30 p.m. in the 1400 block of Broad Street in South Greensburg.
Ms. Gerritsen said she was on her annual Easter trip, and she, her mother, her aunt and her grandfather had just finished dinner at Degennaro’s Restaurant & Lounge on Broad Street. Her mother was at their car, opening the door for her grandfather, and she was right near Mr. Wolff when the accident happened.
“We were going to walk out to the car, and we see the guy’s vehicle way down the road. We had more than enough time to cross. It was like he came out of nowhere, and he hit him,” Ms. Gerritsen said. “It was absolutely awful.”
Her grandfather lay in a pool of blood. She said she slapped the back of the car to get the driver’s attention, and he got out.
“He stopped. He got out of his vehicle. He looked back. He asked if he was OK and then he must have seen the results of what happened, and he got right back in and was gone,” Ms. Gerritsen said.
Mr. Wolff died Tuesday at Forbes Regional Hospital in Monroeville.
Police said the car that struck him was a dark gray sedan.
At the scene of the accident, investigators found a dark gray plastic mirror cap from the driver’s side. They were able to match it to a Chevrolet Cruze, a vehicle they said was captured on video surveillance footage.
On April 24, Crivelli Chevrolet in Mount Pleasant called South Greensburg police Chief Scott A. Fanchalsky to report that a car with front-end damage had been brought to its collision center. The chief contacted a Westmoreland County detective for help and headed to the collision center; the detective didn't show.
It turned out that the car at the collision center was the wrong vehicle.
But the detective, who for some reason went to the dealership location instead of the collision center, stumbled across the right one, according to police.
He found a dark gray 2016 Cruze in a parking lot close to the service center, the chief said. It had damage “consistent with a vehicle pedestrian accident,” according to the complaint.
The driver’s side mirror was separated from the door, the mirror caps on both front mirrors had been recently spray painted black, and there was a fresh paint smell, the complaint said.
Mr. McElroy — whose listing and picture on the Crivelli website still appeared Thursday evening but had been taken down by Friday morning — approached police and told them the dealership car was assigned to him, police said.
“They refer to that vehicle as a 'demo.' He is authorized to operate that vehicle to and from [work]," the chief said. On the day of the accident, he said, Mr. McElroy was driving home from visiting an acquaintance in Greensburg.
Mr. McElroy provided police with a written statement that said that the car was damaged during a dispute at a bowling alley, when he and another man “fell into the vehicle,” the complaint said.
On Wednesday, following Mr. Wolff’s death, police went to Mr. McElroy’s house. He gave investigators a statement in which he admitted to driving the car involved in the accident, leaving the scene and trying to repair the damage.
Police charged Mr. McElroy with accidents involving death or personal injury, tampering with evidence, unsworn falsification to authorities and theft. The chief said Mr. McElroy stole a mirror cover from Crivelli to replace the broken one.
Chief Fanchalsky said that Mr. McElroy told investigators that the crash was an accident. It did not appear that speeding, weather, mechanical malfunction or visibility were factors, the chief said. There was no accident reconstruction team dispatched to the accident, however, and the chief said he did not know why.
There were no indications that Mr. McElroy was driving under the influence, the chief said. The criminal complaint said a small amount of marijuana was recovered from the Cruze; Mr. McElroy was not charged for it.
Mr. McElroy was arraigned Thursday and is being held in the Westmoreland County Prison on $100,000 bail, according to online court records.
A person who answered the phone at Mr. McElroy’s home declined comment. Messages left for the dealership's general manager were not returned.
Mr. Wolff was an Air Force veteran and had worked as a driver/salesman for Braun’s Baking in Greensburg.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.