The construction crew working in an East Liberty backyard suddenly stopped in mid-dig. It was Feb. 28, 2018, and the workers had just removed a concrete slab from a patio built in 1964 that new owners didn’t want. Now, they stared in disbelief at a shallow grave with skeletal remains.

Unknowingly, they had unearthed the answer to a 54-year-old mystery: Where’s Mary Arcuri?

The story within Mary’s story reads like a complex murder mystery. Elements of jealousy, cunning, and dark secrets mix with suspicions, lies, and a personal connection to a renowned and retired missing persons expert. Also, for good measure, there’s a fatal car crash that many believe was a guilt-ridden suicide, reminiscent of the debilitating remorse felt by the murderer in Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart.”

For more than half a century, the story had been that Mary, 36, gathered her clothes and belongings and took off with a man in the fall of 1964, leaving behind her husband, Albert, and their two teenage children. At least that’s the story Albert told the children, relatives and friends, some of whom forever believed he had something to do with Mary’s disappearance.

Advertise with us

Months later, Albert Arcuri, 40, died in a violent car crash in Bloomfield that was officially ruled an accident, but those suspecting him of wrongdoing felt clearly was a suicide.

When the buried remains were found, those who knew Mary presumed it was her. DNA tests conducted by the University of North Texas Center for Human Identification confirmed that shortly before Pittsburgh police issued a press release in February — eight days shy of a year from the discovery.

But while one mystery has been solved, more haunting ones remain: What really happened to Mary Arcuri? And why?

A Gut Feeling

Albert Arcuri, a construction worker, built that patio with the concrete slab in the rear of their home at 5445 Black St. shortly after Mary disappeared. And around that time, he reported that a large freezer had been stolen from his home — an odd and difficult item to take in a burglary. Those who suspected him in Mary’s disappearance note it would be perfect for keeping her body from decomposing before burial in the backyard.

Advertise with us

Albert Arcuri died on May 8, 1965, when the car he was driving at an incredibly high speed crashed into the wall at the former Don Allen Chevrolet dealership at 5315 Baum Blvd. A Pittsburgh Press story noted he was survived by his wife, Mary, a daughter, Donna, 16, and a son, Michael, 15.

Donna Cefalo, 70, of North Strabane vividly recalled being 16 and riding in a car with her mother on McArdle Roadway in Mount Washington when she heard the radio report that her uncle Albert Arcuri had died in the crash.

“When I heard it on the news, I knew my uncle killed her,” said Ms. Cefalo, whose late mother was Mary’s sister. “I knew it when [she disappeared]. I said, ‘Mom, I bet any money that he killed Mary and put her in that freezer. It was so fishy. How could someone take a freezer in broad daylight?”

Ms. Cefalo had been close to her cousin, Donna Arcuri. The two girls, who were the same age and had the same first names, often spent weekends together in the Arcuri’s home. Ms. Cefalo’s divorced sister, who was around Mary’s age, would take Mary to East End nightclubs. That may have led to Mary’s demise, Ms. Cefalo speculated.

“The motive could have been that he thought she was cheating on him. She was a beautiful person. I think my uncle was very jealous of her and very protective.

Advertise with us

“Albert was a very happy person, always joking, never serious. He was a good man, from the little bit I was around him. Whenever I stayed there on the weekends, I never heard them quarrel, never heard them having a disagreement.”

Nevertheless, she said her mother and sister were so concerned about Mary’s well-being that they went to Pittsburgh police to report her missing. Ms. Cefalo said the police didn’t take the report seriously. Pittsburgh police have disputed that they received a missing persons report for Mary.

Ms. Cefalo said the disappearance caused a rift in the family because those who believed Mary had left with a man thought Ms. Cefalo’s sister knew where she had gone.

Forty years passed and Ms. Cefalo reached out to her cousin Donna. They met at a Banksville Road restaurant and Ms. Cefalo immediately told her cousin, “Our family never knew what happened to your mother. If you want my opinion, I think your father killed her.” Her cousin Donna reacted with indifference, she said. The two never discussed it again. After attending a few family events together over the years, they have not been in touch.

Mary’s daughter Donna declined to participate in this story.

Advertise with us

“I’m very sad about this whole situation,” Ms. Cefalo said. “I look at pictures, Everybody was happy. I feel sad always that my cousin is not in my life. I want her in my life.

“I’m very emotional over it. I just knew all those years that my gut feeling was right.”

Godmother of missing persons

Shocked to the core, Therese Rocco just had to sit down in her Brookline home.

“Yes, Mary Arcuri! I know her!” Ms. Rocco told Pittsburgh police Detective Edward Fallert shortly after the remains were found.

Advertise with us

Detective Fallert had just told Ms. Rocco that a Black Street resident tipped investigators that a man named Albert Arcuri was the former owner of the home where the remains had been unearthed. And that his wife had disappeared.

A renowned Pittsburgh police missing persons expert, Ms. Rocco didn’t have a professional connection to Mary’s case but a personal one. Growing up in the lower Hill District, her family knew the Arcuris, who at the time lived nearby until moving to Dormont and then East Liberty. Mary asked the then-teenage Ms. Rocco to be Donna’s godmother, which thrilled the young woman. Since then, Ms. Rocco has had contact with her goddaughter for whom she professed her love.

Detective Fallert had gone to see Ms. Rocco — who retired in 1994 as Pittsburgh’s first female assistant chief — because of her encyclopedic knowledge of missing persons. And because when she retired, Ms. Rocco took copies of all unsolved missing persons cases “because I knew if I left them they were going to get lost.” She occasionally peruses the files stored neatly in her basement to see if there’s something she and detectives missed over the years.

Police initially believed the human remains might be those of Marcella Krulce, a 30-year old who went missing in November 1959 from the former Martinique Apartments in Bloomfield. Ms. Rocco quickly produced the Krulce file and Detective Fallert took a photo on his phone of Ms. Krulce’s dental records. He texted them to headquarters and left. But about 15 minutes later, he returned to say they weren’t a match and told Ms. Rocco of the Arcuri tip.

Property where remains were found

Advertise with us

James Hilston/Post-Gazette

In an interview, Ms. Rocco was adamant that there was no missing persons report for Mary. In fact, she only learned that Mary was gone when Donna told her what Albert Arcuri had told the children. The children lived with relatives in Dormont after their father’s death.

“They believed it, they were convinced, hurt. I had pictured her married again with kids, but I always had in the back of my mind, ‘Why isn’t she trying to find out what happened to these two kids?’ She loved them.

“It was after she [vanished] that the rumors started, that he suspected her of maybe seeing someone else. She was a sweet little girl, petite, pretty and loving. I never knew Albert to be mean. He was soft-spoken, smiled a lot and seemed like a very nice guy. Who would have thought she was under that concrete?”

Using both her police training and common sense, Ms. Rocco said Albert Arcuri had to have been involved.

Advertise with us

“I’ll never forgive him for putting her in the dirt, in the ground, but I kept in my mind that he didn’t mean to kill her. I can’t in my mind picture that Albert would kill her [intentionally]. Something went horribly wrong. It’s a mystery, but there’s no question he’s involved.”

Forensic pathologist Cyril H. Wecht, who has seen all types of strange cases in his long career, agreed that Albert Arcuri had to have been the person who buried Mary. “No one else would have done that. But we don’t know what happened in the house, even though we know the end result.”

And therein lies the rub.

‘Undetermined’ and ‘Undetermined’

When Karl Williams, the Allegheny County medical examiner, and his team of forensic pathologists received the skeletal remains, they had three questions they hoped to answer.

Advertise with us

First, the identity. Because of Ms. Rocco's input, it was presumed that the skeletal remains were Mary’s. The ME’s office hoped to confirm that through dental records. Unbelievably, the ME’s forensic odontologist recognized the dental work as so distinctive that it could only have been done by a certain local dentist. Unfortunately, he had died and his records were missing. That’s why the specialized DNA testing in Texas was necessary for the identification.

The second question was the cause of death, or the medical reason Mary died. The forensic pathologists, who only had bones to examine, could find no trauma to them, such as would have been caused by a shooting, stabbing or beating. There was no choice but to rule the cause of death as “undetermined.”

Finally, there was the manner of death, or how Mary died — homicide, suicide, natural causes, or by accident. Dr. Williams said that given the circumstances, it might logically be surmised that Mary’s death was a homicide.

“You’ve got a husband who doesn’t turn in a missing person report, a husband who tells the kids that their mother ran away with a man and a husband who himself dies under somewhat unusual circumstances. All of that leads you to say it’s got to be a homicide,” Dr. Williams said.

Yet, it was not beyond the realm of possibility that Mary died from an accident, such as aspirating on food. Or from a natural cause, such as an aneurysm. It also was possible that "for whatever reason, [Albert Arcuri] didn't want anyone to know" and buried her, Dr. Williams said. Due to that uncertainty, the manner of death also was ruled as undetermined. And because of that, the case officially remains an open police investigation.

Advertise with us

Having both the cause and manner of death ruled as undetermined is rare. Dr. Williams said his office takes jurisdiction of about 2,000 cases a year, “but this one stands out as being really just about one of the most unusual cases we’ve had in a long time.”

What happened to Mary? The enigma lingers like a long-ago whisper, likely unanswered for the ages.

Michael A. Fuoco: mfuoco@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1968 or on Twitter @michaelafuoco.