If all goes according to plan, by the beginning of July Allegheny County will see its first new regional police department in a half century, after the Allegheny Valley communities of Cheswick and Springdale Township voted to merge their policing this month.
Armed with a finding from the state's Department of Economic Development that a merged department would save both municipalities money while improving policing, Springdale Township's board of commissioners voted 4-0 for the merger, with one abstention, two weeks after the Cheswick Borough Council approved the merger unanimously.
"Most of the operational aspects related to police services won't pose that great of a challenge," said Cheswick Councilman Michael Girardi, an attorney, on Tuesday.
While there are cases in the county in which one municipality contracts its police department out to its neighbors, the Allegheny Valley Regional Police Department will be the first regional department formed in the county since 1969, when the Pine-Marshall-Bradford Hills Regional Police Department was created. In 2006 Richland joined, resulting in the Northern Regional Police Department.
Last year, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette explored in its Patchwork Policing series the county's 100-plus municipal police departments, and the disparities in resources and crime faced among them. Cheswick and Springdale Township are demographically similar and close in population, each having around 1,700 residents.

Cheswick and Springdale Township will contribute equal funds and have each appointed two members to the Allegheny Valley Regional Police Commission. The commission will oversee the department, and over the next two months will have to deal with the logistics of the planned July 1 beginning of operations.
Cheswick appointed to the commission Mr. Girardi and Councilwoman Kathy Gillard, while Springdale Township appointed Commissioner Shirley Redman, who is responsible for policing, and former Allegheny County Council President Rick Schwartz, a resident.
"I just wanted to help. It's my community and I think it's good," said Mr. Schwartz, who moved to the township a little over a year ago.
According to a letter sent to Cheswick residents ahead of the vote, the merger will save Cheswick $90,000 annually and Springdale Township, which currently spends more, will save nearly $130,000.
"We only get about $400,000 a year in taxes, and the bulk of our money is with the police department," said Springdale Township Commissioner Henrietta James, who voted for the merger.
Ms. James pointed out that the township has experience with merged services in its fire department: the Allegheny Valley Volunteer Fire Department serves Harmar and Springdale Township, and Cheswick is in the process of joining it too.
"It shows you can be successful," said Ms. James.
"These fellows came from Harmar, and we welcomed them with open arms,” she said of the firefighting arrangement. “It's going to be the same thing here” with the police.
One priority for the new commission will be selecting a police chief, with one obvious option: current chief of both existing departments, Mike Naviglia. Chief Naviglia has served as Springdale Township chief for 14 years, and started part-time as Cheswick’s chief in December, when the borough's previous chief retired.
"That's going to be something that everyone's going to have to agree upon, but I think it's certainly the logical choice," said Mr. Girardi.
According to Mr. Girardi, they will also have to sort out basic logistics like changing the titles on the equipment, replacing the details with the new department logo, and buying an insurance policy for the department. They will also need to coordinate with state and county agencies, so everyone has up-to-date information on local policing.
While Cheswick does not currently have any full-time officers, Springdale Township does, so the joint department will need to pick up existing commitments including pension funds and health insurance.
Because Cheswick has only part-time officers, the merger will not require any staffing cuts. A similar proposal for a merger of four Fox Chapel Area School District police departments was met with a negative recommendation from the state earlier this year, when it was found that they would have to lay off a number of officers to achieve any savings.
The department will be headquartered in the current Springdale Township Police headquarters, which are larger and more up-to-date than Cheswick's, according to Mr. Girardi. The Cheswick headquarters, which are in the municipal building, will be used as a "substation" by the new department, he said. The commission will also initially meet in Springdale Township.
According to the information sent to Cheswick residents, the merged department will be able to staff full-time officers at more hours, provide more training, and reduce overscheduling of part-time officers.
Municipal leaders and Chief Naviglia have looked as a model to the Evans City/Seven Fields Regional Police Department, which was formed by the two small Butler county communities in 2015.
Tom Smith, Seven Fields Borough Manager and administrator of the regional department, said, "We provided them our charter agreement, our budgets, an overview of any potential pitfalls we experienced.... There's no sense recreating the wheel."
He advised that the municipalities set aside a rainy day fund, for inevitable unexpected complications from merging their departments, but said the merger should "go smoothly."
"I'd be more than glad to help any other municipality looking at regionalism. It's beneficial to the delivery of services and the best way to utilize taxpayer dollars," said Mr. Smith.
Christopher Huffaker: chuffaker@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1724, or on Twitter @huffakingit.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.