Tuna company StarKist Co. pleaded guilty last year to conspiring with fellow seafood companies Bumble Bee Foods and Chicken of the Sea to keep the price of canned tuna high.

But paying $100 million -— the maximum fine that could be levied under the plea agreement — could bankrupt the Pittsburgh-based company and affect its ability to pay restitution to victims, an attorney representing StarKist told a federal judge.

“This is really about the life or death of our company, and its ability to continue as an ongoing concern,” Niall Lynch of Latham & Watkins said on Nov. 14, when the company entered its guilty plea, in U.S. District Court Northern District of California.

The remarks were contained in a transcript that was recently released.

Advertise with us

StarKist is headquartered on the North Shore. It has significant production operations in American Samoa, a United States territory, and operations in Ecuador. The company also has smaller operations in Thailand.

The U.S. Department of Justice has been pursuing the antitrust case against the three largest tuna companies for several years.

The investigation was prompted when the parent company of Chicken of the Sea, Thailand-based Thai Union, announced it would buy Bumble Bee for $1.51 billion. Plans for the deal were dropped in December 2015 after the DOJ said it had “serious concerns” that the merger would harm competition.

After the investigation began, a wave of civil lawsuits was filed by retailers, grocers, wholesalers and suppliers.

And it’s those civil cases that are part of the financial trouble for StarKist, Mr. Lynch said.

Advertise with us

Under the plea agreement, StarKist would be required to pay at least $50 million or a maximum fine of $100 million.

“Now, we’re not walking away from our responsibility here, your honor,” Mr. Lynch told Judge Edward M. Chen. “We’re agreeing to pay, at a minimum, $50 million. It’s just simply $100 million will either bankrupt the company or absolutely impair its ability to pay restitution to victims.”

The company plans to request an evidentiary hearing to make its financial case, which would include expert witnesses describing the “state of the company, what money it has available to pay in terms of a criminal fine, as well as payment of anticipated civil-damage claims which have already been filed,” Mr. Lynch told the court.

“And in order to have a complete record, we think it would be appropriate for the court to hear live testimony.”

The packaged seafood market, which also includes salmon, clams and the like, is a multibillion-dollar industry in the United States. Tuna represents about 73 percent of that market and generates about $1.7 billion in annual sales, according to court documents. But sales have been flagging in recent years.

Advertise with us

The three big tuna players combined controlled 80% to 85% of the U.S. market between 2003-2015, according to court documents.

A reduction in a fine -— the kind that StarKist’s attorney is arguing for — isn’t an unusual move for the courts.

In August 2017, Bumble Bee Foods pleaded guilty to its role in the antitrust conspiracy and agreed to pay a $25 million fine — cut from $136.2 million “due to Bumble Bee’s inability to pay a full criminal fine without substantially jeopardizing the continued viability of the organization,” according to court documents.

In the meantime, StarKist, which is owned by South Korea’s DongWon, and its two rivals have been working individually to settle cases with many of the companies like Walmart, Target, Kroger and O’Hara-based grocer Giant Eagle, which have filed civil lawsuits.

In most of those settlements, financial details have not been disclosed. But in January, StarKist said it agreed to a settlement worth $20.5 million with Walmart, the largest retailer of canned tuna, to resolve antitrust claims.

Advertise with us

Chicken of the Sea was the first tuna producer to act as a whistleblower in the DOJ’s antitrust case.

Three former tuna company executives previously were charged and have pleaded guilty: W. Scott Cameron, a former senior vice president of sales for Bumble Bee; Kenneth Worsham, a former senior vice president of trade marketing for Bumble Bee; and Stephen Hodge, former senior vice president of sales for StarKist.

In May of last year, a federal grand jury indicted Christopher Lischewski, former president and CEO of Bumble Bee Foods LLC, on a one-count felony charge that he carried out the conspiracy. Mr. Lischewski stepped down from the company. He has pleaded not guilty.

StarKist’s sentencing hearing is scheduled for June 12.

Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com; 412-263-4910