A U.S. Supreme Court ruling on Wednesday that says constitutional limits on civil forfeiture in federal cases also applies to the states won't make much difference in Pennsylvania, according to several district attorneys in the Pittsburgh region.

"Our first impression is that the impact on our office should be negligible," said Mike Manko, spokesman for Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.

The high court sided with a drug dealer in the state of Indiana whose $42,000 Land Rover was seized by police after he sold a small amount of heroin to undercover cops.

The justices ruled 9-0 that the Eighth Amendment barring "excessive fines" in federal cases, limiting the ability of the U.S. government to seize property, also applies to forfeiture in state cases.

Advertise with us

Tyson Timbs, the owner of the Land Rover, had pleaded guilty and authorities took his Land Rover.

He sued to get it back, arguing that he bought it with money from his father's life insurance policy, not drug proceeds. He said that the forfeiture amounted to an excessive fine because the value of the vehicle far exceeded the maximum fine of $10,000 that could have been imposed in his drug case.

The Indiana trial judge ruled in his favor, saying the amount of the forfeiture was "grossly disproportional to the gravity" of the offense.

An appeals court agreed but the Indiana Supreme Court did not, saying that the Eighth Amendment prohibition on excessive fines didn't apply to fines imposed by states.

The U.S. Supreme Court has now ruled otherwise and returned the case to Indiana to determine whether the Land Rover seizure amounted to an excessive fine.

Advertise with us

Here in Pennsylvania, however, the decision is expected to mean little.

"Our practices already include ensuring that there is a strong nexus between the assets subject to civil forfeiture and the crime that has been committed and ensuring that the seizure and forfeiture is not disproportionate to the crime," Mr. Manko said in an email. "Additionally, last year the state legislature amended the language in the state's asset forfeiture statute resulting in raising the burden that our office must meet in order to forfeit assets."

David Lozier, the district attorney in Beaver County, said much the same.

"I don't think it changes anything," he said.

He said that a similar seizure in Pennsylvania would not occur because the law here is different. He said the penalty for possession of drugs with intent to deliver, for example, is a fine of up to $250,000 — or a fine sufficient to exhaust the profits of the drug dealing.

Advertise with us

He said the idea is that the seizure of assets should match the crime.

"Again it brings it all back to proportionality, which the Indiana statute lacked," he said.

Eugene Vittone, the district attorney in Washington County, echoed his colleagues.

He said the forfeiture laws in Pennsylvania have been beefed up, with more oversight from the attorney general's office and more stringent requirements for seizure.

For example, he said, the legal standard was changed from more probable than not to "clear and convincing" evidence, making asset forfeiture more difficult.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.