On Tuesday, a judge postponed a homicide trial for an inmate at the Allegheny County Jail because the defendant was dressed in what his lawyer called his “jail reds” for court instead of civilian clothes.

Inmates are supposed to show up for jury selection and trial wearing what prosecutors refer to as “court clothes,” not jailhouse attire.

The county said inmate Branden A. Frazier refused to get changed.

But by Friday two more possible explanations emerged about Mr. Frazier’s clothing situation.

Advertise with us

In a court filing, the district attorney’s office said that on Tuesday it was “communicated that the Allegheny County Jail actually lost the defendant’s clothing earlier that morning.” The source of that information was unclear.

Then the DA’s office cited a trial postponement form filled out by Mr. Frazier’s attorney, Marvin Leibowitz, in which he stated, “The Allegheny County did not give my client court clothes.”

Did the jail lose the clothes, just not provide them, or did Mr. Frazier refuse to get dressed in them?

“We have to find that out,” Mr. Leibowitz said Friday.

Mr. Frazier is charged with beating a 73-year-old man to death in McKees Rocks in 2016. Mr. Leibowitz was concerned that if his client appeared in a jail outfit, jurors might automatically assume he was guilty.

Advertise with us

“It’s clear under the case law that you can’t have a jury trial with an inmate in jail reds,” Mr. Leibowitz said. “You can’t have that. That would be prejudicial to the person.”

Reached late Friday afternoon, Amie Downs, the county’s spokeswoman, said she had no other information about the situation.

Mr. Leibowitz said he spoke Friday with his client.

“They didn’t dress him up in his court clothes. That was my understanding,” he said. “He wasn’t given them. I don’t know if they lost them or what happened...It’s my understanding that he did not refuse to put on court clothes.”

Both sides are scheduled for a hearing Tuesday morning before Judge Sasinoski to set a new trial date. Initially the judge said the earliest his calendar would permit was Sept. 9, but prosecutors grew concerned that might violate something called the “speedy trial” rule that says defendants must be tried within a certain period of time.

Advertise with us

Asked if the prosecution could explain the various reasons given for Mr. Frazier’s absent clothing, Mike Manko, a spokesman for the DA’s office, said, “I’m not going to get into the minutiae of what happened. We will do that at the hearing.”

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.