A former captain at the Allegheny County Jail has sued the county, the warden and a major at the jail, saying she was fired because she’s black, female and in her 50s.
Sandra Stinson, 56, named Warden Orlando Harper and a major, Matt Kohler, in the federal suit filed Friday. She said she was fired in October 2017 for “purportedly mischaracterizing” an altercation between an inmate and an officer as an “incident involving physical contact” rather than a “use of force” event.
She said younger white male captains at the jail have done the same in their reports but haven’t been fired.
She said the real reason that Maj. Kohler fired her was because of her race, sex and age.
Ms. Stinson, a 20-year veteran of the jail, said that she followed procedures after an altercation between someone who had just been arrested and a corrections officer on Sept. 27, 2017.
She said she reviewed a video, talked to witnesses and examined documentation showing that the inmate hadn’t been injured, then filed a report.
Maj. Kohler disagreed with her report but rather than ask her to modify it and submit a different form, as has been the practice in the past, he fired her for submitting a false report, according to the complaint.
Ms. Stinson said a year earlier, a white male captain had submitted a blatantly false report and had not been fired. In another incident, she said, two white male captains failed to report an inmate injury and didn’t get fired.
She also said male guards haven’t been disciplined for other infractions, such as viewing pornography at work, and that female officers are subject to more scrutiny than the men.
According to the suit, most of the corrections officers in charge are younger white men. Of the 44 captains, majors and sergeants, only five are women.
Ms. Stinson said she was the only older black female among them.
She also said she’s aware of other older employees being forced to retire or quit because of a hostile work environment and that younger white men are favored.
When she applied to become a major in 2015, she said, she had all the qualifications for the job, but a younger man was promoted instead.
Her suit is seeking lost wages and compensatory and punitive damages.
The county did not respond to a request for comment but does not typically comment on litigation.
Ms. Stinson had been suspended without pay in December 2016 after an incident in which city police said she initially refused to turn over a video of two people in a car who had pointed guns at the jail in a parking lot near the facility.
A jail officer had reported the pair to police, who pulled the car over and discovered they were jail employees who were "showboating."
A police lieutenant who tried to acquire the security camera footage complained that Ms. Stinson refused to give it to him until she called a duty officer. The lieutenant said he would call the county police, and after a wait of 45 minutes to an hour, a county officer arrived and Ms. Stinson allowed the video to be seen, according to news accounts at the time.
In her lawsuit, Ms. Stinson said she was exonerated in that incident.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.