The massacre of 11 worshippers at a Squirrel Hill synagogue that thrust hatred and racism into the public eye in October followed months of less-violent but still hate-fueled incidents in the Pittsburgh region this year.

Three months before the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue, several people associated with a Pennsylvania white supremacist group attacked a black man in a bar in Avalon. A month after that, a white man appeared to boast on video about using a racial slur shortly before police say he stabbed a black man to death in a fight outside a North Shore bar. In May, a man in West Mifflin hung a swastika flag on his porch that neighbors said was pointed at the home of an interracial couple.

Less than two weeks after the synagogue shooting, neo-Nazi flyers from the hate group Patriot Front were plastered around Brookline; in December, anti-Semitic pamphlets were distributed in Squirrel Hill. That same month, an Etna man who runs a white supremacist music label was arrested in an attack on a black man in Washington state.

“Pittsburgh is not immune to this stuff,” said Keegan Hankes, a senior research analyst in intelligence at the Southern Poverty Law Center. “The disturbing reality is that there are hate groups all across the country. And they’ve been particularly successful at recruitment and radicalization in the last few years.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Hankes said membership in groups like Keystone United — a white supremacist organization founded in Harrisburg in 2001 that was involved in the Avalon bar attack — seems to be on the rise, although it’s difficult to track.

White supremacist and nationalist recruitment and radicalization have moved online, experts said, and while hundreds of thousands of people participate in such rhetoric in chat rooms and on websites and social media platforms, only a small percentage take action in the real world. Even fewer carry out violent attacks.

There are many different facets of white nationalism — some, for example, are blatantly anti-Semitic, some are not — and many different methods of recruitment, experts said. It is difficult for anyone to predict who will be the next violent extremist.

“Whereas decades ago they might have a meeting in Larry’s basement and everyone knows who the leader is and how the hierarchy works, that’s increasingly not the case,” Mr. Hankes said. “We have these typically young men who interact for hundreds of hours online all across the country before they ever meet anyone in the real world. It’s added a new dimension to what’s already been a vexing problem, which is how to track this stuff and stop someone from committing an atrocity beforehand.”

‘White advocates’

Advertise with us

Bill Harvey, 47, of Bellevue was having a drink in the Jackman Inn in Avalon on July 7 when he suddenly heard a commotion in the back room.

He walked toward the shouting and saw an acquaintance, Paul Morris, who is black, being attacked by several white people.

“Paul was on the ground by the pool table, and two of the girls were kicking him and the guys were punching down at him,” he said. “Paul took off running and the bartender is yelling that she is calling the police, and they’re going, ‘Good, call the police!’ Then they all took off out the back and jumped off the deck.”

Police charged four men and two women with the state’s equivalent of federal hate crime charges; investigators noted the attackers wore shirts and had tattoos associated with Keystone United, which the Southern Poverty Law Center characterizes as “one of the most active single-state racist skinhead crews in the country.” The cases are pending trial.

Leaders of Keystone United did not return a request for comment, but claimed in a statement on its website that the charges were bogus. It’s against the group’s policy to attack anyone verbally with racial slurs or use violence “except in cases of self-defense,” the statement said.

Advertise with us

“Our members are being charged with these outrageous charges only because of who they are and because of what they are involved with,” the statement said. “Nothing in this incident was because of racial views — it only turned into something racial when the aggressor used the race card and played victim.”

Keystone United refers to its members as ‘white advocates’ and purports to be a family-friendly club (no women are allowed to be members) that holds picnics and other civic events in order to engage with their communities and provide “a real alternative to the degenerate influences found virtually everywhere today.”

Members of the group have been arrested for violent attacks several times since the group’s founding. In 2006, a Keystone leader, Todd Sager, pleaded guilty to aggravated assault in connection with a Westmoreland County bar fight with a black man who had been at the bar with a white woman.

Mr. Harvey, who is white, said he didn’t hear how the fight in the Jackman Inn started but said if the altercation was about race, that’s “stupid.”

“I mean it’s 2018,” he said. “Maybe 60 years ago you could see people acting like this … but, I don’t know, I guess it’s still the times we live in.”

Advertise with us

‘They want to grow’

The day-to-day white nationalism in Pittsburgh can be hard to see unless you’re looking, said Joe Hawkins, 39, of Pittsburgh. He’s a volunteer with One People’s Project Pittsburgh, which aims to track white supremacists in the city and Allegheny County and alert the public to their activities and identities on its website.

“Most weekends you can spot someone wearing a white power T-shirt in Pittsburgh,” he said, adding later, “They’re not wearing swastikas. That tends to be too risky to wear around town. But if you’re wearing an SS symbol and someone recognizes the symbol, then you can fly your flag without announcing it too too much.”

Mr. Hawkins said the wide reach of the internet has made it more difficult to know exactly how many white nationalists are in and around Pittsburgh.

“In the 1990s and the early 2000s, it was a little more predictable,” he said. “It was a bunch of [expletive] Nazis with a phone number and a voicemail on a flyer. Now every [person] with an internet connection who feels disaffected or disconnected can find an online community.”

Advertise with us

For many people, the path to white supremacy or white nationalism begins with online videos, forums and blogs, said Patrik Hermansson, a Swedish activist who “went undercover” and joined white nationalists in Britain for a year in an attempt to learn more about the movement for his employer, the British advocacy group Hope Not Hate.

“They don’t stand on street corners and ask you to join. It’s the other way around,” he said. “People come to them. So they often have to start with a self-radicalization path, and that’s where you get all the forums and YouTube channels.”

Some groups will use comment sections on news articles as a recruiting tool, Mr. Hankes said, by posting on stories that involve black communities — a crime story, for example — and suggesting race is the reason for the crime.

“Or you might see that story rewritten from a white nationalist viewpoint and reposted on a white nationalist site,” he said.

Mr. Hermansson said he was welcomed into the movement quickly when he first approached them in 2016.

Advertise with us

“They want to grow, they want new people and they want young people,” he said. “As long as you have the basics — you are white and a guy and generally believable — you are welcomed in.”

Most of his involvement with the white nationalist movement happened offline, at real-world meetings and gatherings, he said, but that’s not typical.

“Most people have spent extensive time online — all day, every day — before they go offline,” he said, adding that it’s nearly impossible to track.

“We simply don’t know how many people are online,” he said. “A single person could have five different accounts. But it’s very clearly a small minority that takes violent action. And it’s a minority that meets people in real life.”

Online talk, offline action

Advertise with us

Some white nationalists move from online rhetoric to real-life action by dipping a toe into activities like posting flyers, Mr. Hankes said.

“You’ll hear individuals talking about putting propaganda up as their first experience meeting up with people of similar politics offline,” he said. “A relatively low-risk activity — you might get a slap on the wrist for trespassing or a vandalism charge if you get caught doing it.”

Both Mr. Hermansson and Mr. Hankes said there’s a clear connection between online rhetoric and offline action. The online language of hate directly fuels what happens offline, they said.

In the weeks before the white nationalist rally in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017 that left a woman dead, there was a ramping up in online conversations that led to increasingly larger crowds at several smaller rallies before Charlottesville as the movement’s members got “themselves worked up,” Mr. Hankes said.

But after Charlottesville — one of the largest white supremacist gatherings in decades — the movement largely turned away from public action, he said.

Advertise with us

“Because of the consequences from Charlottesville — legal consequences, people losing their jobs — there are fewer rallies as entry points now, and you’re starting to see more closed-door networking,” Mr. Hankes said.

Some white supremacists never formalize a relationship with an organized group. Robert Bowers, who is charged with attacking the Tree of Life synagogue in which three congregations were conducting Sabbath morning worship services Oct. 27, espoused many of the popular white nationalist conspiracy theories online but apparently did not connect with fellow believers offline before he carried out the massacre.

“It speaks to how vexing the problem of monitoring and intervening to prevent domestic terrorism actually is,” Mr. Hankes said. “There are so many factors that go into how someone who feels alienated gets radicalized. There are some people who are absolutely horrible online and they never take action. There are others online who seem benign and they take action.”

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.