A fisherman who killed his wife on the waters of Lake Erie will spend the rest of his life behind bars.

Christopher S. Leclair, 49, was all but guaranteed to receive a life sentence after a jury in October convicted him of first-degree murder in the death of his wife, 51-year-old Karen Leclair.

Erie County President Judge John J. Trucilla issued the mandatory sentence Tuesday and added three years and nine months to 17 years for charges including abuse of a corpse, tampering with evidence and false reports.

“There was almost a recognizable gasp in this community when this crime was committed,” Trucilla said. “The depravity and depths that you went to calculate this murder are unlike any this court has ever seen.”

Advertise with us

Christopher Leclair, of Elk Creek Township, will never be eligible for parole under the sentence. Trucilla also ordered Leclair to pay $705,974 in restitution to the U.S. Coast Guard for the search that was conducted when Leclair falsely reported his wife had fallen overboard and gone missing on Lake Erie after her death.

Leclair’s lawyer, Bruce Sandmeyer, told Trucilla that Leclair maintains his innocence.

“Mr. Leclair has asked me to let the court know that he continues to assert his innocence,” Sandmeyer said.

Leclair declined to speak in court.

Prosecutors charged that Leclair had a detailed plan to kill his wife that he carried out on June 10, 2017, while the couple was out on their commercial fishing vessel, the Doris-M.

Advertise with us

“His actions, your honor, are so depraved,” Erie County First Assistant District Attorney Elizabeth Hirz said. “It’s chilling what he did that day.”

Jurors agreed that the evidence showed Leclair shot his wife in the head, tied up and weighted down her body with an anchor, and dropped her body into Lake Erie.

Leclair then put out a distress call to the U.S. Coast Guard the next day, claiming his wife had fallen overboard into the lake. The call sparked a massive search that lasted nearly 30 hours.

A boater ultimately found Karen Leclair’s body about 6 miles off the coast of Dunkirk, N.Y., on July 4, 2017.

Christopher Leclair claimed at his trial that his wife was so distraught over an affair he was having that she shot herself aboard the Doris-M. Leclair did not testify at the trial, but in letters written from the Erie County Prison he claimed that he dumped Karen Leclair’s body in Lake Erie because he felt guilty and did not want anyone to know what happened.

Advertise with us

Jurors deliberated for less than two hours before finding Leclair guilty of killing his wife.

The Erie County District Attorney’s Office presented surveillance video footage that showed Leclair boarding the Doris-M with his wife on June 10, 2017, and returning alone later that day. He returned to the vessel by himself on June 11, 2017, shortly before he made the distress call to the Coast Guard.

Leclair had also told acquaintances of a plan to kill his wife and drop her body into Lake Erie on several occasions before his wife disappeared, according to their testimony at his trial.

Leclair’s father, 76-year-old Ernest Leclair, is also awaiting prosecution on one count of tampering with evidence. Pennsylvania State Police charged that Ernest Leclair moved a hidden gun to a new location at the request of his son, who had been incarcerated at the Erie County Prison on charges in his wife’s death.

Ernest Leclair has applied to end his case in Erie County’s Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition program, which allows first-time, nonviolent offenders to end their case without pleading guilty and have their record expunged if they complete a period of supervision.