An Allegheny County judge Tuesday removed an Ingram judge of elections after ordering sheriff’s deputies to bring her before him to assess “credible reports” of her being “under the influence,” according to the order.

Sheriff’s deputies escorted Michelle Paulin to Election Court at the City-County Building, Chief Deputy Sheriff Kevin Kraus confirmed.

The incident began when Ms. Paulin did not show up on time to the District 1 polling location at the borough building on West Prospect Avenue. Polling stations across the county opened at 7 a.m.

Ms. Paulin told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Tuesday evening that  she was not under the influence of anything. She said she was running late because she was taking care of her sick daughter the night before, and she was surprised when Ingram police Chief John Doherty knocked on her door shortly after 7 a.m. and asked her if she had some place to be.

Advertise with us

“Ingram police went to her house. They made contact with her. She showed up at the polls at approximately 7:50 a.m. The constable believed that she was possibly unfit to serve, and a court order was issued by the elections judge for the sheriff’s [office] to transport that individual to appear before him at elections court,” Chief Deputy Kraus said.

__________________

The two court orders issued by the Court of Common Pleas:

Common Pleas order 1 (PDF)

Common Pleas order 1 (Text)

Advertise with us

__________________

Common Pleas order 2 (PDF)

Common Pleas order 2 (Text)

__________________

Ms. Paulin admitted she was late, but she got to the polling place as fast as she could. She was working, helping people understand the machines and handing out stickers when two deputies arrived to take her Downtown.

Advertise with us

Common Pleas Senior Judge Joseph M. James issued an order for Ms. Paulin to be brought before him “for inquiry as to her capacity to serve as there are credible reports as to her condition of being under the influence.”

Ms. Paulin was taken from the borough building around 8:36 a.m. and brought to court on the seventh floor of the City-County Building.

At 9:36 a.m., Judge James ordered that Ms. Paulin “not serve as judge for the remainder of this election. The sheriff shall deliver Ms. Paulin to her home.”

She was taken to her house on Ingram’s Linshaw Avenue a few minutes later. Ms. Paulin said she did not want to continue working anyway, because she was “so embarrassed.”

“She indicated to Judge James that she was fine, but had some issues at home,” according to county spokeswoman Amie Downs.

Advertise with us

Ms. Paulin said she offered to take a sobriety test, but Judge James told her she was not impaired. She said Chief Doherty did not perform a sobriety test, either.

Judge James declined comment, and Ingram police were not immediately available for comment.

“I can’t say that she was under the influence,” Chief Deputy Kraus said. “I can just say it was deemed by the judge that she was unfit to serve as the judge of elections.”

“Apparently other poll workers noticed something and asked for her to be removed,” Allegheny County Solicitor Andrew Szefi said. “The judge made an assessment and an order. I have no independent assessment.”

Mr. Szefi said there were no voting disruptions at the polling site. Another poll worker was sworn in as a judge of elections to replace Ms. Paulin, he said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Paulin, who has been working the West Prospect Avenue polling place for the last four years, said only Chief Doherty and maybe one other person at her polling place may have accused her of being under the influence.

But Ms. Paulin said she does not know why anyone would have accused her. She said shes been a part of the Ingram community for 40 years and rarely drinks.

“It’s a defamation of my character,” Ms. Paulin said. “This is not my demeanor at all.”

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Staff writers Christopher Huffaker and Andrew Goldstein contributed.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.