When De-John Johnson was arrested for allegedly killing his 4-month-old son in 2017, he had a cell phone and the baby's pacifier in his pocket.

The police confiscated both.

Now, more than a month after Mr. Johnson was found not guilty of homicide following a non-jury trial, he has asked to have both items returned to him.

Deputy District Attorney Jennifer DiGiovanni has no problem giving back the cell phone.

Advertise with us

But the pacifier?

No way.

"That pacifier is not owned by De-John Johnson," Ms. DiGiovanni said Monday morning at a hearing on the issue. "And I strongly object to it."

Mr. Johnson was charged following the asphyxiation death of his son, Isaiah Brooks-Leonard, who died on Feb. 6, 2017.

The prosecution pushed for a first-degree murder conviction, arguing that the infant had hemorrhaging beneath his scalp caused by blunt force trauma, bruises on his right cheek and a torn frenulum — the tissue inside the mouth that connects the upper lip and gums.

Advertise with us

Ms. DiGiovanni told Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Anthony M. Mariani during the trial that she believed Mr. Johnson shoved the pacifier into the baby's mouth and then pushed his head hard against a wall next to his bed.

Defense attorney Lisa Middleman argued that Isaiah died accidentally from her client rolling over on him.

Judge Mariani found Mr. Johnson not guilty on Sept. 26.

Five days later, Ms. Middleman filed a petition for return of property.

At the Monday hearing, Ms. DiGiovanni told the judge the pacifier does not belong to Mr. Johnson and should not be returned to him. She said Mr. Johnson has the burden of proving it belongs to him.

Advertise with us

"Mere possession is not ownership," she said.

Instead, Ms. DiGiovanni said that the baby's mother, Iman Brooks-Leonard, provided everything Isaiah needed when he visited his father's McKeesport home that day — formula, clothes, diapers — and the pacifier.

In the late winter, Ms. DiGiovanni said, when she was at Ms. Brooks-Leonard's home to prepare for trial, she showed the young woman a picture of the pacifier.

"She told me she remembered buying that — they came in a two-pack, and she had the other one upstairs."

Ms. Brooks-Leonard doesn’t want the pacifier back, Ms. DiGiovanni told the judge. She just doesn’t want Mr. Johnson to have it.

Advertise with us

“While we respect the court’s verdict, Ms. Brooks-Leonard believes Mr. Johnson killed her child,” the prosecutor said. “She does not want that pacifier going to back to Mr. Johnson.”

Judge Mariani kept questioning the prosecutor about the commonwealth’s interest in the dispute. Ms. DiGiovanni repeated her earlier statements that Mr. Johnson is not the owner.

“I don’t see any standing for the commonwealth to oppose the motion,” Judge Mariani said. “I don’t see any reason not to give it back to the person who possessed it at the time of his arrest.”

He asked Ms. DiGiovanni to provide case law for him to review prior to making a decision.

The parties will reconvene Nov. 20.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.