Federal prosecutors are asking a judge to seal all the discovery material pertaining to accused synagogue shooter Robert Bowers as the case proceeds in U.S. District Court.
U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose gave the defense until noon Monday to respond.
Mr. Bowers is accused of gunning down 11 members of Tree of Life synagogue on Saturday. He was indicted this week on 44 counts and faces a possible death sentence if convicted.
The U.S. attorney's office on Friday said in motions to the judge that the release of discovery materials in the case should be limited to the defense, in this case the public defender's office, and that nothing should be released publicly now or as the case goes forward.
"Because of the nature of the allegations in this case (in particular, that the defendant shot, killed and injured civilians and also shot and injured public safety officers) and due to the sensitive nature of much of the Rule 16 Materials [discovery], the government has significant concerns about the public release of Rule 16 discovery and other discovery into the community," prosecutors Troy Rivetti and Soo Song wrote.
"Another consequence of the release or controlled production of such materials may result in unwanted contact with, and harassment of, victims and/or their surviving family members."
Read More
The prosecutors said the discovery material, which is essentially any government evidence that must be turned over to the defense, should be filed under seal or redacted.
The U.S. attorney's office also requested that a motion the government intends to file be placed under seal because it "pertains to sensitive and confidential information pertaining to the charge at issue."
Government motions in federal cases are often placed under seal to protect witnesses or preserve the integrity of an ongoing investigation.
One example is the federal murder case against accused heroin dealer Price Montgomery, which began this week in Pittsburgh. Montgomery is charged with killing a federal witness and soliciting inmates to kill other witnesses. Many documents in that case have been sealed over the last two years.
The public defender’s office does not comment on cases.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.