________________

A younger sister of the 10-year-old girl who was shot to death with her mother and a man inside a New Castle home witnessed the attack and identified the shooter, according to court records.

Steven Procopio, 19, of New Wilmington, was charged Thursday with three counts of homicide in the deaths of Amariah Emery, her mother, Nichole Pumphrey, 31, and Lawrence Cannon, 31.

Officers also charged another Lawrence County resident, 41-year-old Jody Hammer of New Wilmington, with obstruction of justice.

Advertise with us

All three victims were shot in the head inside Ms. Pumphrey’s house at 819 W. North St. sometime between 8 p.m. Monday and 6 a.m. Tuesday, Lawrence County District Attorney Joshua Lamancusa said Thursday.

Lawrence County DA talks about triple murder in New Castle

Ms. Pumphrey and Mr. Cannon were shot as they sat on a couch on the first level of the house, and Amariah was coming down the steps from the second floor when she was shot, according to a criminal complaint.

Four of Amariah’s siblings, ages 4 to 9, were upstairs during the shooting. Two girls described the attack to police. The girls, who were not identified in court records, said they heard an argument and two “thumps” downstairs. Amariah started down the stairs with another sister behind her, according to court records.

Amariah asked what was going on. Mr. Procopio shot Amariah on the stairs, and then pointed the gun at the second sister but did not fire, the girl told police.

The girls thought their mother was covered in ketchup and did not call for help until the next morning, when they were able to call their grandfather.

Advertise with us

The girls said Ms. Hammer, who they called “Aunt Jody,” was at their house with Mr. Procopio the afternoon before the shooting. One girl worried that Ms. Hammer was going to kill her for talking to police about Mr. Procopio, who they’d known prior to the shooting as “Steven,” according to the criminal complaint.

Ms. Hammer was a “motherly figure” to Mr. Procopio, Mr. Lamancusa said. She is not related to Mr. Procopio, but fed, clothed and cared for him, he said.

“She has taken him into her house, she cares for him, and he truly looks at her as his mother figure and is extremely loyal to her,” Mr. Lamancusa said.

“We have not determined the extent of her involvement, but we believe she played a role either before or after the homicide,” he said.

During an interview with police, Mr. Procopio admitted he was at Ms. Pumphrey’s house during the shooting but pinned the killings on another man, Anthony Cooper. Mr. Cooper lived with Mr. Procopio and Ms. Hammer in a home on Canterberry Road, according to the criminal complaint.

Advertise with us

Police initially brought all three in for questioning. Ms. Hammer and Mr. Cooper told similar stories. Both admitted to going to Ms. Pumphrey’s house in the afternoon, and both said Ms. Hammer went inside while Mr. Cooper stayed in the car outside. They said they were home by 6 p.m. and went to bed.

All three were released after an initial interview, but Ms. Hammer and Mr. Procopio were later brought back in -- Mr. Cooper, however, could not be found; Ms. Hammer said he’d boarded a Greyhound bus to Michigan.

In the second round of interviews, Mr. Procopio gradually told a different version of events. He said he went with Mr. Cooper to the Pumphrey house and that Mr. Cooper said he needed to “take care of business” before going into the house with a gun.

Mr. Procopio said he thought Mr. Cooper was going to rob the house and followed, but he then saw Mr. Cooper shoot the three victims as Mr. Procopio stood in the doorway.

Police are searching for a third suspect in the attack, Mr. Lamancusa said, but he declined to name the person, citing the ongoing investigation. He spoke to reporters before Mr. Cooper’s name was made public in court documents. Mr. Cooper had not been charged.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lamancusa also declined to discuss a motive for the attack, but said authorities do not believe it was a robbery.

“There was money on the table; the house did not appear to be ransacked,” he said.

Mr. Procopio’s mother, Cheryl Procopio, of Pulaski, said through tears Thursday that her son moved out of her house about two years ago and that she does not know Ms. Hammer or the victims.

“My son would never hurt a little girl,” she said. “He’d never, ever.”

She declined to speak further.

Advertise with us

Mr. Procopio is being held without bond in the Lawrence County Jail.

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.

________________

Police spoke to the media Tuesday after they were called to the scene of the shooting:

Three bodies found inside New Castle home