Man serving life for murder confesses to 1988 New Castle slaying
______________
Joe Vascetti had tried to get the confession before.
In October 2014, the veteran Pennsylvania State Police investigator met with Regis A. Brown, an Erie County felon linked to a biker gang, to discuss a cold case. Someone had killed Bryce Kenneth Tompkins of New Castle in 1988 and dumped his body in a nearby creek. Trooper Vascetti believed Brown was the culprit.
It didn't work. Brown denied any involvement, and the trooper let him go.
More than three years later, in March, Trooper Vascetti again confronted. Brown, 59, of Fairview. He had just been arrested for killing his wife and step-daughter in Erie County. This time, Brown was ready to talk.
And talk, and talk and talk.
Authorities announced Thursday that Brown admitted not only to killing Mr. Tompkins -- described as an innocent victim -- but also to committing up to eight murders in total in Lawrence and Erie counties between 1986 and 2016 and having information about as many as 10 more dating to the late 1970s.
Brown has already pleaded guilty to two of them -- his wife and step-daughter -- in September and was sentenced to life in prison. Mr. Tompkins' case makes three murder confessions. And now investigators are trying to close the books on the other cases, at least one of which is suspected of being connected with the Outlaws Motorcycle Club.
"At different areas, different times, random, specific killings. Serial killings," Trooper Vascetti said Thursday, declining to provide details. “There's no underlying theme for a lot of these like you do get for certain serial killers. If you offended him or he had a specific reason, like this case with Tompkins where he witnessed the burglary, he’d kill you.”
Brown was charged with homicide, two counts of aggravated assault and intimidation of witnesses in the Tompkins case.
Mr. Tompkins' body was discovered Dec. 26, 1988, by archery hunters, who found him face down in Neshannock Creek about a mile north of New Castle.
An autopsy determined that the 45-year-old was killed after being shot twice in the back with .38-caliber rounds. Authorities couldn't determine how long Mr. Tompkins' body was in the water, but estimated he was killed between Dec. 18 and Christmas Day.
Investigators quickly focused on Brown along with Paul M. Ayersman, who died two years ago. Brown, a known criminal with what police said was a violent past, lived two doors down from Mr. Tompkins.
“He’s been on our radar the whole time," Trooper Vascetti said. “He’s just a vicious individual.”
"According to a police affidavit, Brown and Ayersman were arrested in December 1988 for a series of burglaries and robberies. Brown had a shotgun and leather jacket that were stolen from a New Castle house a month earlier. Also stolen was a .38-caliber revolver."
In March, Brown told police that he targeted Mr. Tompkins because he had witnessed the burglary while taking a late-night walk. He told police that he shot the victim with the stolen revolver, put the body in an accomplice's vehicle and dumped him in the creek.
After working on the cold case for a decade and keeping Brown under surveillance, Trooper Vascetti and his partner, Trooper Justin Werner, sensed an opportunity after charges were filed in the deaths of Brown's wife and step-daughter. Trooper Vascetti described what happened on March 19:
"We had him in a room. He was defeated, and he knew that he was probably going to serve life, a double life sentence, in the murders. He accepted his role in that. He knew that I knew that he was involved in the Tompkins homicide, and I let him know that, and we just got that out of the air quick. It wasn't a situation where I was asking him. I was telling him. He knew that, and he confessed.”
Trooper Vascetti kept his composure. But inside, he was elated. He had been waiting 10 years — a third of his career -- to close the case and let Mr. Tompkins' family know. One daughter, Kathy Turnbull, the trooper's main family contact, had died several years earlier.
“It’s tough because I wish she was here to enjoy this," Trooper Vascetti said. "It’s sad.”
But another daughter, Stacey Harding, 47, attended Thursday’s press conference and said the charges were a relief. She was a senior in high school when her father was killed.
“After 30 years, I’m completely relieved that we can have closure,” she said.
State police spent the next several months finalizing interviews, fruitlessly trying to find the murder weapon that Brown said he had buried in his back yard, and putting the case together for Lawrence County District Attorney Joshua Lamancusa.
There was no rush.
“It’s been 30 years," the trooper said. "We wanted to take our time.”
Mr. Lamancusa said police do not yet have enough evidence to charge Brown in the other killings, and are working to be sure he is not falsely confessing because he is already serving a life sentence.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Shelly Bradbury: sbradbury@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1999 or on Twitter @ShellyBradbury.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.