A federal judge has ordered the Allegheny County Jail to stop assigning more forced overtime shifts to guards who use the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) than to those who don't take leave.

The ruling by U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab on Thursday ends a lawsuit filed last year by two corrections officers, Debra Nelson and Michael Krah. A third plaintiff had also been part of the case originally but withdrew.

The suit said that when guards use their FMLA leave in lieu of working overtime, they are assigned more forced overtime shifts than if they worked the overtime, causing them to use their FMLA allotment at a faster rate.

Ms. Nelson, for example, used her FMLA instead of working overtime in July 2017 but was assigned 19 overtime shifts. As a result, 136 hours were deducted from her FMLA allotment.

Advertise with us

Officers who did not take FMLA leave and worked their mandated overtime in July 2017 were assigned forced overtime only an average of two to five times that month. When Ms. Nelson worked overtime in December 2017, according to court papers, she was assigned only three overtime shifts.

Judge Schwab said the jail's policy "all but guarantees that an employee who cannot work overtime because of an FMLA qualifying reason will soon exhaust that time and be subject to discipline and ultimately to termination."

The judge granted an injunction against the practice. The county had no comment on the ruling.

Judge Schwab rejected a second claim that the jail was acting in retaliation against those who take leave because the policy has been in place since 1996 and treats all officers who refuse mandated overtime equally, whether or not they use FMLA.

Margaret Coleman, one of the lawyers who represented the officers, said that the jail has for years assigned all guards a large number of overtime shifts but that some can't work them because they have medical problems or have to take care of someone else who does.

Advertise with us

But when an officer uses leave instead of working the shift, the jail deducts from their FMLA allotment and then "almost immediately" assigns them another forced overtime, often on the next shift.

"As of yesterday, the jail is prohibited from enforcing this policy," Ms. Coleman said.

The judge said the jail's practice "clearly frustrates" the purpose of the FMLA to allow employees to take a reasonable amount of leave and still maintain their employment status.

“Our clients have always believed that the Allegheny County Jail’s forced overtime policy is unfair to them and violates their federal rights," said Ms. Coleman. "This injunction vindicates them and sends a clear message to all employers that they may not adopt overtime policies that discriminate against FMLA recipients or interfere with their ability to use their leave.”