A prosecutor said Tuesday that a former Uptown pizza shop manager who police say beat up a Homestead woman in January while ejecting her from the restaurant should be found guilty of assault.
But the manager's lawyer said the woman has herself to blame because she was drunk and obnoxious and refused to leave the pizzeria despite repeated requests.
An Allegheny County Common Pleas Court jury heard those differing views Tuesday on the first day of trial for Mahmut Yilmaz, the manager at Pizza Milano at the time of the incident on Jan. 12.
Mr. Yilmaz, 41, is charged with aggravated assault and simple assault in an attack on Jade Martin, 34, which was captured on a cell phone video and store security cameras.
Jon Pittman, the prosecutor, said in his opening statement that Ms. Martin had been drinking at a bar after work and then planned to catch a bus home. She wanted to go inside the restaurant, which was near the bus stop, but he said Mr. Yilmaz wouldn't let her in.
When she came in, he said, Mr. Yilmaz grabbed her, threw her up against a wall and slammed her to the ground. During the attack, he said, Mr. Yilmaz may have also head-butted her and banged her head off the ground, although he said it is hard to tell from the video.
The recording will be the government's key piece of evidence.
"What you saw on the video is an assault," Mr. Pittman said.
He said it will be up to the jury to determine if the assault was aggravated, meaning that Yilmaz intended to badly hurt Ms. Martin.
He also reminded the jury that "Ms. Martin is not the defendant" and is not on trial.
But James DePasquale, Mr. Yilmaz's lawyer, said the jurors will have to consider her actions that night.
"It was Jade Martin who forced the confrontation," he said. "Jade Martin's conduct is on trial."
He said she had been thrown out of the bar where she was drinking with a friend after work and had twice been confronted by police that evening before she arrived at the pizzeria. He said she was "ranting" on her cell phone near the door when an employee told Mr. Yilmaz that a drunk woman was outside causing a disturbance.
Mr. Yilmaz went out and asked her to leave because she was blocking the door. Ms. Martin then pulled out her cell phone and said she would take a picture of Mr. Yilmaz so her boyfriend could come and shoot him, Mr. DePasquale said. Mr. Yilmaz went back in and called 911.
Mr. DePasquale said Ms. Martin then walked into the pizzeria. "She's staggering drunk, she's obnoxious, she's bothering people," he said.
Mr. Yilmaz told her to leave but she would not, Mr. DePasquale said. As she tried to push past him, he said, he grabbed her and they fell to the ground.
"It is true that he loses his patience with her," said Mr. DePasquale of the violence.
But he said she is at fault for trespassing. He also said that she has a history of "multiple altercations" for which she has been treated at UPMC Presbyterian, where she went after the incident.
"This is not her first rodeo," he said.
To bolster that argument, he pointed to the aftermath of the Pizza Milano incident. A police officer is seen on the video talking to Ms. Martin on the sidewalk and holding up three fingers, Mr. DePasquale said, indicating that it was the third time that night that police had to deal with her.
The trial is expected to last a couple of days.
Pizza Milano Facebook video





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.