The attorney for a woman accused of running over a man in Ross last year and leaving him there wants the jury in her upcoming trial to know that the victim had a high blood alcohol content.
During a hearing Friday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, Melinda Gregor’s lawyer told Judge Beth A. Lazzara that Michael Menner’s blood alcohol content of 0.294 — more than three times the legal limit for driving — could be considered a contributing factor of the crash.
“It’s very relevant, and it’s very probative as to who actually caused the accident,” attorney Phil DiLucente said after the hearing.
But Assistant District Attorney Ryan Kiray, who opposes the blood-alcohol level being admitted during the trial, said that, under the crimes charged, it doesn’t matter who caused the accident, but whether Ms. Gregor left the scene.
"The critical question before the jury in this matter would merely be whether or not the defendant knew that she was involved in an accident involving death or serious bodily injury,” Mr. Kiray wrote in a motion on the issue. “[W]hether or not the recipient of that injury was intoxicated has no arguable or actual bearing upon what the defendant knew or did not know.
Judge Lazzara said she would review the cases submitted by Mr. DiLucente before making her decision but that “at this point, I am somewhat skeptical.”
Read More
Jury selection in the case is scheduled for Aug. 20.
Ms. Gregor, 29, of Ross, is accused of striking Mr. Menner, 50, a Shaler attorney, around 7 p.m. on Dec. 17 in the 2300 block of Babcock Boulevard.
She is charged with accidents involving death, speeding, careless driving and driving without a license.
Surveillance video from the accident shows that Mr. Menner parked his car across the street from Shenanigan's Bar and Grill, walked to the edge of the road, looked both ways and waited for traffic to pass before jogging across, police said.
He was struck by Ms. Gregor's car just past the center line of the road, police said.
Mr. Menner was carried about 90 feet on the hood and windshield of her white Subaru before falling off.
Police said Ms. Gregor’s vehicle was moving 46 mph right before the crash despite a speed limit of 35 mph. In addition, it was dark and had been raining that night.
Investigators said Ms. Gregor did not wait for police or report the crash.
Mr. DiLucente argues that for the commonwealth to prove the charge of accidents involving death, it must show that his client "knew or should have known" that she struck a person that night.
"Did she have knowledge she was involved in an accident with a person, not an animal?" Mr. DiLucente said.
Judge Lazzara countered, "Had she stopped, she would have known whether it was a deer."
"She did stop, your honor," Mr. DiLucente answered. He would not provide any further detail on that issue after the hearing.
Judge Lazzara told Mr. DiLucente that causation of the accident is not an issue for the crimes charged, and instead, as the commonwealth alleged, it appears the defense is “trying to bring it in to attack the victim’s character.”
Mr. Kiray argued that admitting Mr. Menner's level of intoxication would be prejudicial to the prosecution "because it could significantly sway a jury based on a limited view of Mr. Menner's character.
"Such a consideration would be improper, and the potential for such unfair prejudice substantially outweighs any limited probative value that the toxicology report may have."
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.