Anthony Calaiaro, who embezzled $827,000 from his father's law firm and pawned his mother's stolen jewelry, stood before a judge Wednesday and explained why he did it:
Drug addiction.
"I'm deeply ashamed for having done what I did," he said.
U.S. District Judge David Cercone sympathized but was not moved enough to let Calaiaro, who said he has been sober for two years, avoid a federal penitentiary.
"It's horrible, it's terrible," the judge said of Calaiaro's narcotic dependency. "But it's not a defense."
He sentenced Calaiaro, 34, of Castle Shannon, to 21 months behind bars and ordered him to repay the money to Calaiaro Valencik, the Downtown bankruptcy law firm where he had worked as the office manager for two years.
Read More
Calaiaro had admitted that he forged checks on the Allegheny Valley Bank business account of the firm, where his father, Donald Calaiaro, is a partner, and used them for himself.
Donald Calaiaro had brought his son aboard the firm and vouched for him. The younger Calaiaro handled invoices, checks and payroll.
He didn't have signatory authority over the business account, however.
So he forged the name of a partner and made some 525 checks payable to himself between June 2014 and April 2016.
He then falsified the descriptions for the checks in the check register to conceal his thefts, making it look like the checks had been used to pay vendors.
Later, when money began running out, he prepared six checks totaling $28,000 made payable to the law firm and drawn on the firm's Interest on Lawyers Trust Account at Allegheny Valley Bank.
He forged a signature on the checks and deposited them into the business account so he could continue writing checks for himself.
Calaiaro's mother, Patricia Enright, asked for leniency from the judge, saying her son is a recovering addict whose life may have been damaged by her divorce from Donald 20 years earlier. She said he got addicted to narcotic pain pills but has been in rehab.
"He has been clean and is doing very well," she said. "He's a good person."
But the judge noted that Donald Calaiaro did not share that opinion, noting that his son had lunch with him and his law partner three times a week while working at the firm and came to his house for family gatherings on weekends, all the while fleecing him behind his back.
"It was a deep betrayal," Anthony Calaiaro agreed, although he said he and his father have long had a strained relationship.
Judge Cercone also noted that Calaiaro pilfered jewelry from Ms. Enright, with whom he lives, and sold it to support his drug and gambling habits.
"I mean, he stole from his own mother," the judge said. "Does it get much lower than that?"
In asking for prison, Assistant U.S. Attorney Lee Karl said Calaiaro's crime was not an impulsive lapse in judgment but a calculated white-collar fraud as indicated by the 525 forged checks, the altering of records to cover his tracks, and the fact that he stopped only when he got caught.
"That was 525 times he made a decision" to steal, Mr. Karl said.
Calaiaro apologized and said he's no longer the same person now that he's been in drug treatment.
"It's been a long road to where I'm at now," he said. "Two years in, I still have a long way to go."
Calaiaro's father did not appear in court, and the law firm has had no comment on the case. The partners did say previously that none of their clients lost any money.
Mr. Karl said Donald Calaiaro tapped his personal savings to make sure the account that contains client money was secure.
Judge Cercone allowed Calaiaro to self-report to prison by Oct. 12.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.