The defense attorney for Kylee Lankford, accused of killing two women in McKeesport last year, told jurors Friday they shouldn’t believe a word that came from either of the prosecution’s key, cooperating witnesses at trial this week.
Cameron Kirk, who was given immunity by the prosecution for his testimony, told the court that he gave a gun he’d been carrying to Miras Kelly II early on the morning of Sept. 1 and then went home. A short time later, he testified that he heard gunshots, and minutes after that, he said Mr. Kelly and Mr. Lankford arrived at his Dale Street apartment. It was then, Mr. Kirk continued, that Mr. Lankford admitted shooting Kimberly Lesko and Melodie Robb in the face.
And Mr. Kelly, who faces homicide charges of his own in the case but was offered a plea deal of 10 to 40 years in prison, gave similar testimony, telling the jury Thursday that he went into the Gross Street home with Mr. Lankford that morning. Although Mr. Kelly admitted having the gun he said Mr. Kirk gave him, he said it was Mr. Lankford who shot both women and a man staying in the house who survived.
“I submit to you Cameron Kirk lied to you. He lied to you repeatedly,” attorney Ralph Karsh said in his closing argument. Later, he continued, “If the only word you have to take is Miras’, you don’t have anything to believe.”
The jurors, who are hearing the case before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Alexander P. Bicket, will begin deliberating on Monday.
During closings, Mr. Karsh tried repeatedly to push the blame from his client to Mr. Kirk, noting that Mr. Kirk’s girlfriend, as well as Mr. Kelly testified that it was Mr. Kirk who always carried a gun with him — despite Mr. Kirk denying that on the stand.
Read More
But Assistant District Attorney Brian Catanzarite told the jurors in his closing that Mr. Karsh’s argument doesn’t make sense.
“Did Cameron Kirk do it himself?” the prosecutor asked.
He then recounted for the jury the evidence that he presented supporting the commonwealth’s case.
Ms. Robb’s husband, who had been upstairs at the time of the shooting, heard two voices in the living room just before the women were killed.
There is video surveillance, time-stamped at 2:49 a.m., showing Mr. Lankford and Mr. Kelly running back to Mr. Kirk’s apartment.
And, he continued, Mr. Kelly’s testimony implicated both himself and Mr. Lankford.
“That was a confession you watched on that stand,” Mr. Catanzarite said. “He told you he knew they were going in there for a robbery, that he had a gun.
“Why on earth would Miras Kelly put himself in that position to cover for Cam?”
Mr. Catanzarite also reminded the jury that Mr. Kirk and his girlfriend testified consistently about Mr. Kelly’s behavior when he returned to their apartment right after the shooting.
They both described Mr. Kelly as having been in shock, shaking and unable to speak.
And, the attorney said, even though in Mr. Lankford’s interview with police he denied having committed the crime, he admitted to being with Mr. Kelly at the time the shootings occurred.
“There’s corroboration upon corroboration upon corroboration,” Mr. Catanzarite said.
Paula Reed Ward; pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.