Commonwealth Court has affirmed a lower court decision that California University of Pennsylvania cannot be sued for negligence in connection with a man’s 2014 beating by a group of university football players.
The university claimed sovereign immunity, under which an entity or employee of the state is immune from civil liability when acting under the scope of employment, unless one of nine exceptions is met.
Lewis Campbell III sued the university and athletic director Karen Hjerpe, alleging that the university recruited players dismissed by other schools for criminal violations and disciplinary problems, and that posed a danger to the community. Mr. Campbell’s claims for negligence and institutional negligence were dismissed by Washington County Common Pleas Judge Katherine B. Emery in August.
Mr. Campbell subsequently appealed to Commonwealth Court. In its sovereign immunity claim, the university argued its recruitment process was part of the school’s responsibility as a state entity.
“In the context of sovereign immunity, it is immaterial that the university is not expressly authorized by statute to establish and maintain athletic programs such as its football team,” Commonwealth Court Judge Ellen Geisler wrote in an opinion handed down Friday.
“Instead, we must analyze this matter considering the connections between the university and its football team, the university and Dr. Hjerpe and Dr. Hjerpe and the university’s football team. ... It is clear that both the university and Dr. Hjerpe are clothed by sovereign immunity’s protection in this situation.”
Mr. Campbell was attacked while walking on Wood Street near campus Oct. 30, 2014. Police said a football player, Corey Ford, made a derogatory statement to Mr. Campbell’s girlfriend, Shareese Asparagus. As the players left the scene, the lawsuit said, they chanted “football strong.”
Police charged Ford, as well as D’Andre Dunkley, Shelby Wilkerson, Jonathan Barlow and Rodney Gillin. Charges against James Williamson were dismissed.
Ford, 25, pleaded no contest to aggravated assault and was ordered to serve 23 months in prison. The other defendants all pleaded guilty to simple assault and were ordered to serve 18 months of probation.
Kevin Flowers: kflowers@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.