A man who spent 27 years in prison for the rape of a New Kensington woman that he has long claimed he did not commit won a new trial after a judge on Wednesday vacated his conviction because of skepticism over physical evidence.

John Kunco, 52, had a message for state prosecutors as sheriff's deputies prepared to transport him from the Westmoreland County Courthouse to the county prison, where he was released to his waiting family.

"The commonwealth really needs to know what they're doing before they put an innocent man in jail," he said. "After 28 years, they still don't want to let it go."

Common Pleas Judge Christopher A. Feliciani ordered that Kunco be released on a $10,000 unsecured bond. The judge allowed Kunco to stay with his nephew, Mike Kunco, 33, of McKees Rocks, a tow truck operator who said he can get his uncle a job at the same company.

Advertise with us

The judge told John Kunco that he needs to lean on his family now, after being locked up for so many years.

"Mr. Kunco, good luck to you, sir, " said the judge.

The judge said the assault was one of the most egregious he had ever dealt with on the bench. But he also said a review of the state's prosecution led him to believe "it's possible an innocent man has spent 30 years in jail."

During an impromptu news conference after he was released Wednesday night, Kunco said, “Right now I'm still trying to take it all in and it's probably going to take a while to adjust to everything. I'm glad that I had the people that I had working with me because this would have never happened."

John Kunco is released from prison

Asked what he felt was taken from him, he said, “My whole life. They took everything away from me for no reason. I just got to try to get it all back again."

Advertise with us

He continued, “It's going to be hard to get back into the swing of everything because of everything I had to go through. I'm not just going to be OK overnight. It's going to take a little bit of time. And it's an adjustment for everybody, I think."

Asked whether he ever thought he would see this day, he said, "No. It was hard. I didn't think anyone wanted to listen. But these people at the Innocence Project, they wanted to listen. They helped. And if it wasn't for them, I'd still be in there today."

Kunco’s victory was engineered by the Innocence Project, an organization that investigates possible wrongful convictions and which took up his cause after he sought their help. The group said the case was adjourned for 90 days to allow the district attorney to decide how to proceed.

Karen Thompson, an attorney with the Innocence Project in New York who was in the Greensburg courtroom, was elated by the decision.

"I couldn't be more thrilled," she said. "We never expect anything until it's done."

Advertise with us

Kunco, 52, was convicted in 1991 of raping and torturing a 55-year-old woman over a six-hour period at an apartment building in Westmoreland County where he had been a maintenance worker. The attack occurred Dec. 16, 1990. Kunco was sentenced to 45 to 90 years in prison.

Judge Feliciani ruled in favor of a new trial after listening to arguments over DNA evidence recovered from blood found on a blanket at the crime scene. The DNA did not match Kunco’s and is from an unknown male.

“How do you get past the fact that it’s not his blood?” Judge Feliciani asked.

Assistant District Attorney James Hopson countered that the fact his blood was not found doesn't mean he was not there.

Assistant District Attorney James A. Hopson said, "absence of evidence is not evidence of absence."

Advertise with us

John Kunco's trial

Prosecutors said they will appeal the decision. But if they end up retrying Kunco, they will face numerous challenges. Not only is the physical evidence in dispute, but the victim is dead and the original rape kit prepared by New Kensington police is missing.

Other evidence is also questionable, the judge noted.

Kunco’s conviction was partly based on a bite mark on the back of the victim’s left shoulder.

Two forensic dentists, Michael Sobel and Thomas David, examined the bite marks left on the woman five months after the rape and said they had “reasonable dental certainty” that they belonged to Kunco.

In 2016, the two dentists filed an affidavit — prompted by revised guidelines from the American Board of Forensic Odontologists — that said that “while our testimony in Mr. Kunco’s trial was consistent with the scientific understanding at the time, we no longer offer the bite mark linkage opinions that we offered in 1991, that Mr. Kunco was the biter.”

Advertise with us

During the investigation, authorities asked the victim — who was blindfolded during the rape in addition to being partially blind — to make a voice identification of her attacker. A police officer, who never met or spoke with Kunco, imitated Kunco’s voice, including his distinctive lisp, according to the Innocence Project. The woman said the voice was Kunco’s.

The judge called the bite mark analysis and mimicry “problematic.”

He said the DNA evidence combined with the other "frailties" of the case, including the discredited bite-mark analysis, led him to conclude that Kunco should get a new trial.

Prosecutors said they intend to find the victim’s boyfriend at the time and test him for DNA as well as a police officer who handled the crime scene to rule them out as the sources of the blood.

Kunco has maintained his innocence from the beginning and has filed numerous appeals in state and federal court over the years. In addition to the problems with the physical evidence, he and his lawyers raised another defense, saying he has a strong alibi in that the landlord of the building where Kunco worked said in a deposition in 1995 that he was talking to Kunco on the phone at the time of the attack.

Advertise with us

Kunco's family expressed relief at his release but also anger at the prosecution.

His niece, Patricia Kunco of New Bethlehem, said many in the family had long believed he didn't do it.

"We always kind of knew that something didn't sound right from the paperwork," she said.

Kunco's 27-year-old daughter, Loren Kunco of McKees Rocks, visited him in prison until age 5 but hadn't seen him since. She learned about him from her mother.

"I grew up hearing stories," she said. "I think I always knew, if you look at the original case, that he was innocent."

Advertise with us

She said a family party, as suggested by other relatives, was "premature" because her father first needs to adjust to the outside world.

Kunco, asked what got him through all the years in prison, said, “Hope. Talking to [my daughter] on the phone."

On his daughter, he said: "It's going to be hard for a while for both of us because we've got to get to know each other again.”

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.