The proportion of COVID-19 infections and hospitalizations among vaccinated Pennsylvania residents rose sharply last month, though the shot remained broadly protective, according to new statewide health data released Friday.
The latest Department of Health data on so-called “breakthrough” infections shows that between Sept. 5 and Oct. 4, vaccinated people represented just over a quarter — 26% — of more than 135,000 new infections and nearly 5,000 hospital admissions across the state. Death statistics for the last 30 days were not available because of lags in reporting and verification.
Dr. Brian Lamb, an internal medicine physician at Allegheny Health Network, confirmed in an phone interview that breakthrough cases were rising in Allegheny County.
“We are seeing breakthrough cases with our patients who have had both their vaccinations,” Dr. Lamb said, though he noted that vaccinated patients are still safer than non-vaccinated ones.
“There have been some hospitalizations for people who have been vaccinated, but right now what we’re seeing from a personal level in a lot of clinics, although we’re seeing breakthrough cases, most of the patients are tending to have mild symptoms, they are tending to not get nearly as sick as patients who haven’t had the vaccine,” he said.
Dr. Graham Snyder, medical director of Infection Prevention and Hospital Epidemiology at UPMC, warned that looking at breakthrough cases alone is not recommended when determining how well the vaccine is working. Dr. Snyder said you also have to look at the amount of vaccinated people who aren’t sick.
Read More
“The more that people get vaccinated, the higher proportion that you would expect to get sick,” Dr. Snyder said, “even if the vaccine is working similarly well.”
Dr. Snyder also mentioned that the vaccine’s effectiveness works well when looking at any single exposure — as opposed to repeated risky behavior.
“If people are minimizing the number of exposures, the vaccine will look like its doing better, because overall you’re less likely to become sick or hospitalized or die,” Dr. Snyder said. “But if people have repeated exposures, so if they don’t limit the number of times they’re exposed, the vaccine can work just as well, but eventually it will fail.”
Dr. Lamb similarly suggested that social health guidelines were still necessary to mitigate any potential risks of COVID infection for vaccinated individuals.
“With the sheer amount of delta that is circulating, it’s still out to get you,” he said. “The vaccine isn’t 100 percent, you know, you can’t just say ‘Hey I've had my vaccines and I'm going to go and just do everything that I normally would want to do.’ You still have to take precautions to protect yourself. You need to wear masks when you’re in large groups, you need to really think about what people are you associating with.”
According to Dr. Lamb, COVID immunity from vaccines will wane over time, meaning CDC-approved booster shots are recommended to bring protection back up. Dr. Lamb said boosters bring immunity back up in the high 90s percent range.
Even after boosters, Dr. Lamb anticipates at least some risk of breakthroughs.
“There’s still 5 percent of people who are at risk,” he said. “So I wouldn’t be surprised if we are going to see some breakthrough cases in patients who are triple vaccinated or have had their booster.
When the Health Department released its initial set of data on breakthrough cases Sept. 14, just 6% of cases and 5% of hospitalizations since January were among vaccinated residents.
State health officials attributed COVID-19’s increased impact on vaccinated people to the rise of the highly transmissible delta variant of the coronavirus, along with waning immunity among some populations that have received the vaccine, among other factors.
“The vaccines were designed to prevent severe illness and hospitalization, but no vaccine is 100%,” the state’s acting physician general, Dr. Denise Johnson, said in a phone interview. “As we have more people vaccinated, there will be more cases in those vaccinated people. It doesn’t mean the vaccines aren’t working. They’re working as designed.”
She said the data reinforced the case for booster shots. Last month, U.S. health officials approved a third dose of the Pfizer vaccine for all Americans 65 and older, along with higher-risk younger people.
“We know that the vaccines do give a great measure of protection,” Dr. Johnson said. “Even now, with the delta variant, with the waning immunity, the cases that we have, the hospitalizations that we have, people who are really ill, are still largely the unvaccinated.”
On Tuesday, Commonwealth Partners, a free-market advocacy association based in Harrisburg, released weekly Health Department data that it obtained through an open-records request that showed similar increases in cases and hospitalizations among vaccinated people — along with rising deaths.
Those statistics covered a period between late April and late August and showed the spikes were particularly pronounced after delta became the dominant strain of the virus. About a third of the state’s deaths from early July to mid-August were among vaccinated residents.

Gina Diorio, the group’s public affairs director, accused the administration of Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf of seemingly concealing the more recent COVID-19 trends when state health officials released the first batch of breakthrough data last month.
“In September, [the Health Department] had to know that the current numbers were different from what they were releasing. Why not give Pennsylvanians current info? What’s to hide?” Ms. Diorio said. “Ultimately, this is about transparency. It shouldn’t have taken a Right-to-Know request for the Wolf administration to release this info to the public.”
Dr. Johnson said the focus last month was on gathering and analyzing voluminous year-to-date data on breakthrough infections, which she called a “huge lift for us,” with a lot of manual work involved. She said it wasn’t a policy choice.
“It was just a stepwise process for us, to get the huge backlog of data first and then try to analyze it and parse it out later. It just took us a lot of work to get there,” she said.
Over the last month and since the beginning of 2021, the state’s data indicates that Pennsylvania residents who remain unvaccinated against the coronavirus were far more likely to contract COVID-19, become hospitalized and die than those who got the shot.
Last month, even as the state was in the grips of delta, unvaccinated people had triple the risk of being infected and landing in the hospital, the numbers show.
Since January, the risk of death was six times as great among unvaccinated residents. At least 518 vaccinated residents have died, about 7% of the 2021 total.
The Post-Gazette’s Jesse Bunch contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.