Inside a small, welded metal box is a view into the hearts and minds of the Tree of Life Congregation as they were more than seven decades ago.
After hours of sawing at the box, archivists cranked it open like a tuna can in 2024, its contents spread onto a folding table in a workroom behind the Heinz History Center’s Detre Library and Archives.
Irwin Harris, a longtime congregant, remembers that the items, tightly packed in the 1950s, released a musty odor as stagnant air that had been bottled up for decades filled the room.
“It's taking you back into that time,” said Harris, 69, of Squirrel Hill, one of the few people present for the unboxing. “We may put different things in today for reasons only known to us.”
Historians say the time capsule serves as a rare insight into what its members cared most about, and, perhaps, how they wanted to be remembered. Among the contents of the box: an events calendar, membership list, prayer book — and a wire recording of services on the first day of Rosh Hashana in 1952, with the rich, melancholy voice of the cantor pouring out.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · The first day of Rosh Hashana at Tree of Life in 1952
“The whole reason we save these things is so that we can go back and understand in a literal way what happened in the past,” said Eric Lidji, director of the Rauh Jewish History Program & Archives at the Heinz History Center.
“It's a moment of connection where you're getting to listen to a voice that didn't know if anybody would hear it.”
Discovering the time capsule
Archivist Catelyn Cocuzzi was processing some materials from the Tree of Life Sisterhood when she came across a document that caught her eye.
Cocuzzi and Lidji cross-referenced the findings with newspaper articles from the 1950s, indicating that a metal box was buried inside the congregation’s cornerstone made out of limestone flown in from Jerusalem.
The history center then reached out to the congregation about the discovery, its historians eager to recover whatever made it inside.
At the demolition site of the Tree of Life Congregation on Wilkins Avenue, where 11 worshippers were killed in 2018, Lidji said he stood on top of a large pile of brick, stone and metal surrounding one small post that hadn’t yet been knocked down.
That’s when they found the box — in February of 2024.
“It was tucked up inside of it, so we had to kind of wiggle it free,” Lidji said.

As Lidji unpacked the items from the box at the history center last week, most now stored in the museum’s archives, there was a hint of the same musty smell from when it was first opened several years ago.
Inside was a calendar of events and a membership list, as well as a yarmulke, tallit and a prayer book that would have been used for Shabbat and the three festivals: Passover, Shavuot and Sukkot. On the back of the folded photograph of congregation officers is a note that says “to be left in the box,” penned in bright blue ink.
“The point of a cornerstone from engineering is to have a perfectly level foundation that you build a building on. So then, metaphorically, it turns into this idea of, ‘what are we building for?’ ” Lidji said.
“They're thinking, ‘what's the essence of who we are?’ ”
After the 162-year-old congregation relocated from Oakland to Squirrel Hill in the mid-1900s, the time capsule was placed in the cornerstone of the new Tree of Life synagogue on Wilkins Avenue in October of 1952 as part of a dedication weekend for the new building, Lidji said.
The box also held a paper with the introductory comments spoken at the dedication ceremony annotated in green pen, marked up with notes to the speaker about references to names in the speech.
The recording of the Rosh Hashana services — taped on a metal wire and stored in its own cardboard box — was likely taken several weeks before the formal dedication ceremony, he said. The recording was digitized sometime in the spring after the box was found.
It is notable that an organ can be heard on the recording, Lidji said — and even more surprising that the service was even recorded at all.
Rabbi Herman Hailperin, he said, leaned into the idea of a “theatrical service” challenging some traditional laws pertaining to the type of “work” that is usually allowed.
“Traditionally, you would not play a musical instrument on a holiday, certainly not in a synagogue,” he said. “You’re also not allowed to use electronic recording devices.”
Lidji said it’s common for congregations to introduce a new building to the community during a major holiday with high turnout like Rosh Hashana: the Jewish New Year when observers eat round challah bread and apples dipped in honey symbolizing wishes for a sweet year ahead.
Records show that the Rosh Hashana service was held at the Young Men and Women’s Hebrew Association in Oakland. The service was led by Rabbi Hailperin and guest cantor Felix Groveman.
“In this historic season in our beloved Tree of Life,” the booming voice on the recording says, “we ask all of thy blessings upon its members, upon its president, upon its board of trustees, upon all the men and women who are responsible for leadership to show us the way.”
A second time capsule
When the earlier Tree of Life synagogue on Craft Avenue in Oakland was demolished, a second time capsule was found in 2019, its pressed-in lid allowing water to seep inside.
Immediately after opening it, historians peeled and dried the pages of documents after it was removed. Because the 1952 capsule was welded shut, its items were much more intact upon opening.
Notably, the older time capsule held a lot of personal items like envelopes, business cards, a white seashell and a Heinz pickle pen.
“It almost feels to me like people were making those decisions at the event itself, like maybe either they opened it up and told people they could do that, or somebody said, ‘I want to be remembered,’ and threw their thing, and then everybody started throwing stuff in,” Lidji said.
“What do you have on you that says who you are that you're willing to get rid of?”
The differences between the two time capsules also say a lot about how the congregation evolved over nearly 50 years — and what they valued most, he said.

The 1906 time capsule has many more documents written in Hebrew than the one made in 1952, signaling more comfort with the language that may have gradually decreased over time, Lidji said.
But the most telling understanding gained from the capsules is intangible.
Lidji said the 1906 time capsule seems to stem from a congregation that was still finding its footing and gaining its sense of confidence. By 1952, as the congregation grew, it appeared to have a better sense of its own identity and was proud of its accomplishments.
“A lot of this stuff, it's less informational … it reflects these two moments in time for this congregation,” he said. “It's easy to figure out the dates and the names of people, but the sense of what it felt like … it can be very hard to pick up from the record, and there's something about these that I feel conveys that.”
Still, some things have stayed the same. Recently, about 50 new families joined the Tree of Life congregation. Lidji said the box’s documents show the same happened around the time of the dedication, when a junior congregation was formed.
“A congregation is about the people,” said Alan Hausman, 67, of Squirrel Hill, the immediate past president of Tree of Life. “The synagogue is the building.”
Harris, who is also a current officer for the congregation, said there have been talks about placing a new time capsule into the congregation’s reimagined building at the corner of Shady and Wilkins.
“I'm confident that one will go in,” Harris said.
“I'm just not sure what may be in it.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.