The Allegheny County Health Department announced Monday that it was fining U.S. Steel $1.8 million for excess hydrogen sulfide emissions at its Clairton Coke Works plant.

“This particular order that we've issued today is based on the ambient air standard set by the state of Pennsylvania incorporated into Allegheny County Health Department's regulations,” said Shannon Sandberg, the county Health Department’s air quality chief enforcement officer, at a news briefing on Monday.

The Health Department found that there were 153 days since 2020 when hydrogen sulfide levels at a county air monitoring site exceeded state air quality standards.

Residents have long complained about the pollutant, a colorless gas with a characteristic rotten-egg smell. Exposure to low concentrations of hydrogen sulfide can cause eye irritation, headaches, fatigue, poor memory and balance problems, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. For people with asthma, exposure can make breathing difficult. Hydrogen sulfide can linger in the air for up to 42 days, depending on the weather.

Advertise with us

Located about 15 miles south of Pittsburgh, the Clairton plant is the nation’s largest producer of coke, an important fuel source for making steel. It’s created by baking coal at very high temperatures, a process that releases a lot of pollutants into the air.

Following a 2018 fire at the plant that destroyed pollution controls, people with asthma living within a 10-mile radius of the coke works had an 80% increased risk of worsened symptoms, according to a 2021 study published in the Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. The study found that symptoms returned to normal after the plant was repaired.

The federal Environmental Protection Agency does not include hydrogen sulfide in its air quality standards but Pennsylvania does. The state limits concentrations of hydrogen sulfide to 0.005 parts per million per 24-hour period, but people can smell the gas in the air at even lower concentrations.

“Residents often file complaints about smells that they're experiencing, but smells don't automatically equal violations,” Ms. Sandberg said.

The process to investigate those smell complaints and determine whether the level of hydrogen sulfide in the air exceeded what the state allows has taken over a year, she said.

Advertise with us

From Jan. 1, 2020 through March 1, 2022, the Health Department’s air quality team analyzed data recorded at the Liberty Borough air monitoring station. In a report released last week, the Health Department found that hydrogen sulfide levels at the Liberty site exceeded the state limit during 46 days in 2020, 94 days in 2021, and 13 days from Jan. 1 to March 1 of this year.

Landfills and wastewater treatment plants also produce emissions of hydrogen sulfide, or H2S, but Ms. Sandberg said the Health Department’s air quality team evaluated and ruled out other potential sources of the pollutant.

“The study demonstrated that the only source of the H2S exceedances was the Clairton Coke Plant,” she said.

U.S. Steel’s Clairton plant has previously been hit with several fines from the Health Department related to air pollution. But Monday’s fine is the first penalty issued by the county against a single source for hydrogen sulfide levels that exceeded Pennsylvania’s ambient air quality standards. The $1.8 million penalty was determined by several factors, including the number of violations, the severity of each violation and U.S. Steel’s compliance history. The order requires U.S. Steel to either pay or appeal the penalty within 30 days.

In response to the fine, U.S. Steel questioned whether the excess emissions could be solely attributed to its Clairton Coke plant.

Advertise with us

The Health Department “bases the fine on data obtained from the Liberty air monitor that collects data from multiple sources, most of which have no relation to U.S. Steel’s operations,” the company said in a statement. “Any resolution of the regional H2S issue must consider all sources of H2S that impact the Liberty air monitor.”

The company said it has attempted to study the contributing factors of hydrogen sulfide at the Liberty Air Monitor jointly with the county health department but those efforts have been unsuccessful.

“U.S. Steel remains committed to doing its fair share to protect the air quality in the communities in which we live and operate,” the company added.

The company announced in October that it was canceling a planned $1.5 billion emission control upgrade to its Mon Valley Works, which includes the Clairton plant. By next year, it also plans to shut down three batteries at the Clairton Coke Works that are nearly 70 years old. A coke battery consists of multiple ovens to heat coal into coke.

Myron Arnowitt, Pennsylvania director of the environmental advocacy group Clean Water Action, commended the Health Department’s actions. “This fine is significant and demonstrates the company’s disregard for our clean air laws,” he said in a statement.

Advertise with us

Other advocates say the fine is a start but hope the county Health Department does more to prevent pollution stemming from the Clairton plant.

“Hopefully, this is the first of many steps the health department will take to rectify this issue once and for all because Mon Valley communities have endured poor air quality for far too long,” said Patrick Campbell, executive director of GASP, the Group Against Smog and Pollution, which is based in Edgewood.

At a March 2 Allegheny County Board of Health meeting, several residents voiced concerns that the fines against U.S. Steel amount to a slap on the wrist and have not led to better air quality for residents.

“We want to put confidence in the public that what they're saying to us is being taken seriously,” Ms. Sandberg said. “We are looking to make sure that we have 100% compliance and we are trying diligently to make sure that we evaluate all sources of pollution in the county and hold everyone accountable who is contributing to this pollution.”

Emily Mullin: emullin@post-gazette.com