WASHINGTON — Nearly 40 states filed a wide-ranging antitrust lawsuit against Google on Thursday, saying the tech giant manipulates its search results to give its own products and services greater rankings over rivals, depriving web users from seeing the best options whenever they query the Web for shopping, dining, travel and more.
The lawsuit by the state attorneys general marks the third competition case that U.S. regulators have filed against the search-and-advertising giant since October, reflecting the rising unease with Google’s massive profits and expansive reach and the growing national dissatisfaction with Silicon Valley writ large.
In the latest legal salvo, Democratic and Republican attorneys general from states including Colorado and Nebraska take aim at a broad swath of Google’s digital empire. They say Google has solidified its monopoly in search — capturing roughly 90% of all queries — through an array of anti-competitive tactics, such as special deals to ensure that it is the default option on Web browsers, smartphones and newer connected devices, such as smart televisions and speakers.
State investigators also criticized Google for the way it presents its search results, which often requires companies to purchase ads if they want to rise to the top of users’ pages. In doing so, Google is able to drive adoption of its own advertising products and services, enriching its bottom line and further entrenching its dominance.
“Google’s anticompetitive actions have protected its general search monopolies and excluded rivals, depriving consumers of the benefits of competitive choices, forestalling innovation, and undermining new entry or expansion,” said Phil Weiser, the Democratic attorney general of Colorado. “This lawsuit seeks to restore competition.”
Google sought to rebut the charges in a lengthy blog post. Adam Cohen, the company’s director of economic policy, said the search giant’s business practices reflect a desire to deliver more information to consumers — not stifle competitors.
“We look forward to making that case in court,” he said, “while remaining focused on delivering a high-quality search experience for our users.”
Google for years dodged U.S. antitrust scrutiny. Nearly a decade ago, federal watchdogs similarly probed Google out of concern that it had been acting anti-competitively; a government agency concluded its inquiry in 2013 without bringing a case against the company and its sprawling search business. The U.S. ultimately stood alone in opting against seeking massive penalties against Google, even as European regulators issued a battery of punishments - and roughly $9 billion in fines — over allegations that the tech giant acted anti-competitively.
Now, though, Google faces a political and regulatory assault aimed at the very heart of its business. On Wednesday, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton led nine fellow Republican officials in suing Google over its advertising practices, saying the tech giant illegally sought to suppress competition and reap massive profits from targeted advertisements placed across the Web.
Less than two months earlier, the Department of Justice filed an antitrust case. The complaint took aim at Google’s special arrangements to ensure that its search engine is set as the default option on an array of devices, including Apple’s iPhone, and services, such as the Mozilla Firefox browser. Google denies the charges that its practices violate federal competition laws.
On Thursday, Colorado, Nebraska and other states’ attorneys general said they would seek to consolidate their lawsuit with the Justice Department’s earlier complaint so the cases would be argued together. Much like the earlier lawsuits, the Democratic and Republican state leaders opened the door for a judge to order broad penalties, including potentially forcing Google to sell off its business. They stopped short of calling explicitly for Google to be broken up.
“It’s not that people use Google. It’s that Google uses people,” said Nebraska Attorney General Doug Peterson, a Republican, at a news conference.
Search represents the historical and financial core of Google’s empire: It generated $98 billion in revenue for the company last year, which the states said dwarfed the gross domestic product of 129 countries and 46 states. To preserve those profits — and maintain its monopoly — the attorneys general said Google for years has turned to a series of illegal, exclusionary practices.
With its massive financial war chest, Google has long paid a wide array of companies — including its own competitors — to ensure that it is the default search service on many products and services. The company pays Apple, for example, between $8 billion and $12 billion annually to be “enthroned” as the preset search engine on the company’s iPhone devices, the attorneys general say.
Investigators estimate that Google’s special deals have helped it become the default search service on 80% of Web browsers. It has also tied its search engine to the Android operating system, further pushing its service to billions of smartphone users worldwide. And Google has expanded its exclusionary deals to home assistants, ensuring that the next generation of search tool — from smart speakers to connected car — also generate traffic for Google.
Google’s special deals also have created special headaches for companies including Yelp, a reviews site, and TripAdvisor, a travel search service, which for years have asked regulators to intervene. These firms generally must rely on Google in order to attract traffic and customers. But Google heavily restricts these companies in the way they can advertise — and even in their ranking on the search results page — in a move that state officials said seeks to constrain their growth. In the process, Google promotes its own restaurant reviews and travel offerings, according to the lawsuit, which drew praise from the company’s fiercest critics.
“Bringing an antitrust case against the most powerful company in the world requires determination and courage, so we applaud the cooperative, bipartisan work of the state attorneys general and all the staff involved in this lawsuit,” said Luther Lowe, the senior vice president for public policy at Yelp. “We hope today’s action is the beginning of a return to a more vibrant and open Internet.”
Google, however, argued that antitrust regulators around the world already concluded that the way it presents search results is not anti-competitive. Changing its approach threatened to “harm the quality of your search results,” said Mr. Cohen, the company’s economic policy director, adding it would “come at the expense of businesses like retailers, restaurants, repair shops, airlines and hotels whose listings in Google help them get discovered.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.