A chancellor search at the University of Massachusetts, Boston, that had narrowed to three finalists — including a University of Pittsburgh administrator — was scuttled after faculty representatives challenged the qualifications of all three, and the contenders withdrew.
Leadership searches on college campuses sometimes fail, and individual candidates have been known to withdraw themselves from consideration at the last minute, suddenly altering the trajectory of deliberations.
But the departure of all three finalists was an unusual twist in a campus ritual that typically is structured to include representation from all campus stakeholders, but nevertheless often draws complaints that some views — particularly those of professors — are not adequately considered.
In this case, challenges were raised to both the finalists and the search process itself.
Among the three finalists was Kathy Humphrey, Pitt Senior Vice Chancellor for Engagement, who also is secretary of the board of trustees and an associate professor in the School of Education.
Also on the short list were:
• Peter Lyons, Vice Provost and Dean of Perimeter College, Georgia State University, and;
• Jack Thomas, president, of Western Illinois University.
A campus spokeswoman at UMass was not immediately available Tuesday for comment, nor was Ms. Humphrey.
UMass acknowledged the failed search in a statement posted to the campus web site.
“It is with profound disappointment that I write to inform you that all three finalists recommended by the UMass Boston Chancellor Search Committee have withdrawn from consideration, bringing to an unceremonious end a seven-month search process,'' said UMass President Martin Meehan.
He said that after the finalists visited the campus last week, “the UMass Boston Faculty Council decided to take their dissatisfaction with the candidates public, questioning the personal and professional qualifications of three accomplished higher education leaders and demonstrating that the faculty council would not participate in the kind of partnership necessary for a new chancellor to succeed.”
He said all three finalists conveyed “extreme disappointment” and said they were no longer interested in being considered.
Mr. Meehan said the candidates were asked to visit as a way to gather confidential feedback from the campus community that would help him decide which name to recommend to the board of trustees.
“I was mortified when the candidates’ commitment and qualifications were questioned in public forums, including the news media and social media,” Mr. Meehan said.
“I have apologized personally to each of them on behalf of the campus community. I know the majority of you do not support the sensationalized critiques of these candidates’ professional and academic qualifications and accomplishments.”
The University of Massachusetts is the Commonwealth’s public research university system, and includes UMass Boston and campuses in Amherst, Dartmouth, Lowell and the UMass Medical School in Worcester. UMass Boston has 14,000 undergraduates, according to the school’s enrollment management web site.
The unusual outcome has cast a spotlight on the search that extends well beyond Boston. The Chronicle of Higher Education noted that “widespread use of search consultants, the decline in shared governance, and the politicization of higher education have all contributed to the marginalization of faculty input in searches.”
Representatives of the faculty council could not be reached Tuesday.
According to the Associated Press, Mr. Meehan and the faculty council have been at odds over the UMass System's decision to acquire the assets of Mount Ida College, and the council last week released a statement of no confidence in the president and the system's board.
The head of the search committee, Henry Thomas, criticized the faculty group's action and what he said was a "lack of respect for African-American leadership,'' The Boston Globe reported on its web site. Two of the three finalists, including Ms. Humphrey, are African-American.
Mr. Meehan said there were calls to reopen the search. However, after soliciting views including those of the search consultant, he said he is assured it would be futile to do so at this time. The campus for now will be headed by an interim leader.
“The search just completed was both exhaustive and comprehensive. Every avenue was pursued. Both traditional and non-traditional candidates were considered,” he said. “There is no untapped pool of talent awaiting a call.
“But perhaps more significant, the very public way this search came to an end, with three finalists all withdrawing in the face of public opposition from members of the campus, renders a new search untenable at this time.”
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.